That criticism resurfaced following the 2026 NFL Draft, with some analysts accusing the 49ers of reaching on several selections—an issue that has surfaced in previous draft classes as well.
Several recent draft picks have failed to develop into long-term contributors. For example, only two of the nine players selected in the 2022 NFL Draft remain on San Francisco's roster—quarterback Brock Purdy and offensive lineman Nick Zakelj—and none from the first five rounds.
That inconsistency prompted one fan to ask NFL insider Tom Pelissero, while guest-hosting The Rich Eisen Show, whether Lynch should be fired if the 49ers' 2026 draft class fails to produce.
Pelissero made it clear that he does not believe the success or failure of one more draft class will affect the job security of either Lynch or Shanahan.
"I don't see a world where John Lynch ever gets fired by the 49ers," Pelissero said. "Same thing with Kyle Shanahan. They have stabilized that franchise. If you remember how things were for several years before they got there, it was a constant churn. It was the end of the Jim Harbaugh era, which became the Jim Tomsula era, which became the Chip Kelly era. The 49ers are competitive year after year."
Pelissero also noted that San Francisco has managed to offset several draft shortcomings through trades and free agency.
At the same time, the 49ers have found significant value in the later rounds of the draft. Pelissero highlighted players such as Purdy, tight end George Kittle, and linebacker Fred Warner as examples of the organization's ability to uncover talent outside the early rounds.
"Top of the draft, bang for the buck hasn't always been there," Pelissero added. "I don't think it's a matter of do you fire John Lynch. If anything, at some point, could John Lynch decide, I've had enough, and I'm going to walk away, I'm going to go into an emeritus role."
Pelissero went on to review several of the 49ers' top draft selections during the Lynch-Shanahan era, pointing to several notable misses—including the costly trade-up for quarterback Trey Lance—while acknowledging a few hits.
"You'd like to land more superstars in the draft," Pelissero concluded.
You can watch the full segment here:
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers roster building: Why John Lynch's offensive line approach raises concerns
Now that we are close to the end of training camp and the cutdown is a week away, all general managers will be watching the final games. They know they will have to release players they like and that other GMs will, too. They know they will need depth at certain positions, and... -
Why 49ers' Kyle Shanahan refused to name players who stood out vs. Raiders
A few San Francisco 49ers players made positive impressions on head coach Kyle Shanahan during Thursday night's preseason win over the Las Vegas Raiders. However, Shanahan opted to remain tight-lipped about his personnel evaluations, giving reporters little insight into his... -
Why 49ers coach Kyle Shanahan calls the organization 'refreshing,' even amid drama
The San Francisco 49ers have endured a drama-filled 2026 offseason. There have been bizarre actions involving wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk, who remains on the team's reserve/left squad list. Head coach Kyle Shanahan was also involved in a car accident in July, limiting his... -
49ers GM John Lynch addresses Jed York arrest for the first time
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch was interviewed during the Bay Area broadcast of the team's preseason finale against the Las Vegas Raiders on Thursday. It marked the first time the executive publicly addressed the arrest of 49ers owner Jed York over the...