On Monday, the Detroit Lions traded David Montgomery to the Houston Texans in exchange for a fourth-round pick in 2026, a seventh-round pick in 2027, and interior offensive lineman Juice Scruggs. Reports had surfaced that Montgomery was disappointed with his workload last season—a sentiment that's understandable given his proven ability as a timeshare back who can shoulder more responsibility than Detroit allocated to him in 2025. The Lions saved roughly $3.5 million by trading Montgomery.
Montgomery, 28, carried the football 158 times last season for 716 yards, averaging 4.5 yards per carry and scoring eight touchdowns. The year prior, in 2024, he saw a bit of an increase in workload, with 185 carries for 775 yards (4.2 yards per carry) and 12 scores. Despite his productivity, the Lions—much like the 49ers with Christian McCaffrey—found it difficult to take the ball out of the hands of Jahmyr Gibbs, whose electric playmaking skills make him an elite-level three-down back.
Detroit Lions head coach Dan Campbell has consistently expressed a desire to return to the physical, run-heavy, play-action pass approach that brought the Lions success in the past. While Gibbs is dynamic and versatile, Detroit's offense thrives when complemented by a powerful, between-the-tackles runner and someone quarterback Jared Goff can trust on third down picking up the blitz—a role Montgomery filled, but one that now sits vacant.
This is where 49ers pending free agent Brian Robinson Jr. enters the chat
Brian Robinson Jr. profiles as the perfect replacement for Montgomery. Last season with the 49ers, Robinson Jr. carried the football 92 times for 400 yards, averaging 4.3 yards per carry and scoring two touchdowns. At 6-foot-1 and 225 pounds, he brings the size and physicality Campbell covets—a true "thumper" who can handle short-yardage and goal-line duties, while also spelling Gibbs and keeping Detroit's ground game balanced.
Robinson Jr.'s best season came in 2024 with Washington, where he totaled 799 rushing yards and eight touchdowns on 187 carries. His overall skill set aligns seamlessly with the Lions' offensive philosophy, and he's a veteran who can be trusted to pick up those exotic third-down blitzes.
He's proven capable of grinding out tough yards and sustaining drives, and his experience in a timeshare role makes him an ideal complement to Gibbs. With Montgomery's departure, the opportunity for Robinson Jr. to step into a significant role in Detroit's backfield is straightforward.
Robinson Jr. didn't complain once last season while backing up McCaffrey, and unless he prefers to be more of a feature back, which would in all likelihood come on a poor team, spelling another dynamic runner like Gibbs seems like the perfect fit.
Spotrac projects that Robinson Jr. will earn $3.1 million annually on his next contract.
Written By:
Bob served as a site editor for two FanSided sites from 2018 to 2025. He has also been a contributor to 49ers Webzone, part of USA Today Sports, since 2022. A lifelong sports enthusiast, Bob has written and edited numerous articles across both networks. In addition to sports writing, he has taken on creative writing opportunities in the past, crafting slogans and articles for clothing companies and analyzing odds for various sports betting outlets. When he isn't writing, Bob manages his family farm, established in 1928, and is the president and owner of Bob Heyrman Farms LTD. During his downtime, he enjoys dining in beautiful downtown Detroit and attending various sporting events.
All articles by Bob Heyrman
Bob Heyrman
Bob served as a site editor for two FanSided sites from 2018 to 2025. He has also been a contributor to 49ers Webzone, part of USA Today Sports, since 2022. A lifelong sports enthusiast, Bob has written and edited numerous articles across both networks. In addition to sports writing, he has taken on creative writing opportunities in the past, crafting slogans and articles for clothing companies and analyzing odds for various sports betting outlets. When he isn't writing, Bob manages his family farm, established in 1928, and is the president and owner of Bob Heyrman Farms LTD. During his downtime, he enjoys dining in beautiful downtown Detroit and attending various sporting events.
All articles by Bob Heyrman
Nobody's perfect. Did you find a mistake in this article? Report it.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers named potential landing spot for pass rusher with 132 career sacks
The San Francisco 49ers are likely to be connected to several pass rushers this offseason. The team desperately needs reinforcements after finishing the 2025 season with just 20 sacks—the fewest in the NFL by a wide margin. San Francisco was linked to another veteran edge... -
49ers have interest in re-signing Brian Robinson Jr.
Running back Brian Robinson Jr. spent just one season with the San Francisco 49ers, playing 17 percent of the offensive snaps while serving as the primary backup to Christian McCaffrey. Given that limited role, it would be understandable if Robinson explored opportunities... -
Why Cameron Jordan is a perfect fit for the 49ers in free agency
The San Francisco 49ers haven't been shy about retooling the defensive line, and the latest move makes it clear they're still prioritizing disruption up front. With former Dallas Cowboys interior defensive lineman Osa Odighizuwa now in the fold, the 49ers have added another... -
49ers make their splash, landing Mike Evans on a three-year deal
The 49ers came into this offseason with a clear problem and addressed it right away in free agency. They needed a real outside 'X' receiver, a proven, boundary winner who can survive on an island and draw a safety over the top, which makes life easier on others, particularly...