According to ESPN insider Jeremy Fowler, tension between Aiyuk and the 49ers may stem—at least, in part—from how the receiver handled his rehab from the torn ACL and MCL he suffered in October 2024.
"A few people I've checked with believe an issue was Aiyuk's failure to show up for rehab appointments during the offseason," Fowler reported. "Either he didn't trust the trainers or didn't want to show up. Either way, an unwillingness to properly rehab a significant knee injury as the team sees fit is typically easy grounds for a guarantee void."
Most around the league expect the situation to ultimately lead to Aiyuk's release. However, Fowler notes that a trade—while less likely—shouldn't be ruled out, even with the severity of Aiyuk's injury.
"A few teams I spoke to believe Aiyuk is slightly more tradeable with the voided guarantees, though with the option money still technically on the books, reworking his deal altogether would be the preferred method," Fowler wrote. "And Aiyuk might not want that. Getting released and hitting free agency in March would be the cleanest path for him -- and he would have suitors. He's only 27 and had 1,342 yards in 2023."
Could the 49ers trade Mac Jones?
San Francisco protected itself at quarterback by signing Mac Jones to a two-year deal, giving the team control of his rights through the 2026 season. Jones' performance while filling in for injured starter Brock Purdy has only boosted his value and may turn him into a legitimate trade target next offseason.
Jones threw for 2,151 yards, 13 touchdowns, and six interceptions across eight starts while Purdy recovered from turf toe. During that stretch, the former first-round draft pick surpassed 300 passing yards three times and posted five multi-touchdown games.
Fowler highlighted Jones as one of the top potential trade candidates among high-end backup quarterbacks.
"Two interesting names from the high-end QB2 realm are San Francisco's Mac Jones and Houston's Davis Mills," Fowler wrote. "Both are under contract in 2026 at reasonable salaries. Jones has played his way into real trade value for San Francisco, which might be able to parlay a Day 2 pick for him."
The 49ers will eventually have to decide what matters most in 2026: adding another draft pick or keeping a trusted, experienced backup behind Purdy. It's hard to imagine San Francisco being 8-4 at this point without Jones on the roster.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers GM John Lynch sends clear message on Brandon Aiyuk's status
Officially, wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk remains on the San Francisco 49ers' roster, albeit on the reserve/left squad list. Unofficially, Aiyuk has nothing to do with the team at this point. General manager John Lynch made that clear on Monday. Matt Maiocco of NBC Sports Bay... -
Former 49ers star delivers blunt criticism of Brandon Aiyuk
Most San Francisco 49ers fans may have forgotten about Brandon Aiyuk until NBC Sports Bay Area's Matt Maiocco asked general manager John Lynch about the wide receiver this week. Lynch's comments suggest the 49ers aren't thinking much about Aiyuk either, despite the disgruntled... -
49ers 2026 Roster Tracker: Cut-down to 53 players
The San Francisco 49ers have started their 53-player roster cut-down. Below is a list of players reportedly being let go by the 49ers or placed on injury lists to start the season. It will be updated as roster moves are reported. The 49ers have until Sunday, August 30, at 3... -
NFL insider shuts down speculation about 49ers TE George Kittle setback
Speculation surrounding San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle's status emerged after comments made by head coach Kyle Shanahan last week. Shanahan used the phrase "taken a step back" while discussing the All-Pro tight end, leading some—including Pro Football Talk's Mike...