Would they go pass rush and try to take a shot at now Denver Bronco Bradley Chubb? Would they take the emerging star in Los Angeles Chargers defensive back Derwin James? The possibilities were almost endless and the fans were excited to get 2018 underway.
Well, the 49ers surprised a lot of people and took Notre Dame tackle Mike McGlinchey. I'll even say myself that at first reaction, I was a little disappointed. I thought there were some "flashier" players they could have taken. But as the days went on and I evaluated the roster, the pick made a lot of sense.
Perennial Pro Bowl tackle and 12-year veteran, Joe Staley, is nearing the end of his career and left tackle Trent Brown was coming off the injured reserve list after having surgery on his shoulder. Not to mention that Brown wasn't a fit for head coach Kyle Shanahan's system, which was confirmed a day later when the 49ers traded Brown to the New England Patriots.
It was safe to say that at that point, the tackle position was a big need.
We are now six games into 2018 and it appears that the 49ers have hit a grand slam on McGlinchey. McGlinchey's name isn't one that's been mentioned a lot on game day and for good reason. He is doing his job and he's doing it very well.
When it comes to offensive lineman, no news is good news. When linemen's names start to come up it's generally because of what they have been doing wrong. They give up sacks, miss key blocks in the run game, excess penalties, etc. Rarely are they talked about when they are doing what they are supposed to.
McGlinchey has already established himself as a top tackle in the NFL. Pro Football Focus has graded McGlinchey as the 10th best tackle in overall grades and as the best run blocking tackle in football as of Week 5.
McGlinchey is also the top graded rookie lineman in 2018 through Week 5.
It's plays like the one below that show McGlinchey's raw strength and his ability to take on pass rushers. Chargers DE Melvin Ingram is a solid player and this doesn't happen very often, let alone by a rookie. McGlinchey makes statements like this weekly.
In a season that started out with high hopes and has nearly hit rock bottom before the halfway point, McGlinchey has been outstanding. He is proving he can be a key piece for the 49ers for years to come.
It may have not been the "flashy" pick that the fans wanted but, it's currently proving it may have been the best option. McGlinchey has All-Pro potential and will eventually take over Staley's spot to protect franchise quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo.
In year two of a full roster rebuild, selecting a tackle that could lock down one side of the line for the next decade at an elite level was the right move.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Writer excited to see Mike Evans become 49ers' go-to perimeter target
Mike Evans shocked the NFL landscape by turning down a contract with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and signing with the San Francisco 49ers at a reduced rate. The move marks just the second NFL team of his career after 12 seasons in Tampa Bay. Evans already owns a Hall of... -
49ers' George Kittle raves: 'I'm all-in on Mike Evans'
San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle is convinced the team's biggest free-agent addition, veteran wide receiver Mike Evans, will make the offense even more dangerous during the 2026 NFL season. Kittle has already seen the impact firsthand. Evans reportedly stood out... -
49ers already seeing the Mike Evans effect before the 2026 season
On March 12, 2026, the San Francisco 49ers stunned the NFL by prying Mike Evans away from the only franchise he had ever known. He may be 33 before the season-opener in Australia and heading into his last seasons, but that shouldn't take away the fact that the 49ers brought in... -
49ers fans take note: NFL insider warns 'the 18-game slate is coming'
San Francisco 49ers fans would undoubtedly welcome another opportunity each season to watch their favorite team take the field. According to one NFL insider, that extra game is likely on the horizon—it's simply a matter of when the league and players can agree on the...