In The Athletic's latest 2025 rankings, Purdy remains in the second tier but slid two spots to No. 14 following a down statistical season and a disappointing 6-11 finish for the 49ers.
The top tier, led by perennial stars Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow, and Josh Allen last year, welcomed two additions this year—Lamar Jackson and Matthew Stafford.
RELATED
Tier two consists of nine quarterbacks, with Purdy ranking last among them. He received seven fewer votes from the 50 NFL coaches and executives surveyed, placing him behind quarterbacks like Jordan Love, Dak Prescott, Baker Mayfield, and Jared Goff.
"He does more on tape than I think a lot of guys can do in terms of the anticipation and accuracy," an opposing coach told Sando. "Yes, it faltered at times. I also got the sense he was playing through some things. But when he is healthy and on, I don't think there are a lot of guys who are at the level he is at."
Sando highlighted that Purdy leads the NFL in EPA (expected points added) per pass play over the past three seasons and ranked fifth in the category in 2024. Yet, as one NFL defensive coordinator noted, opponents tend to focus more on stopping the 49ers' dynamic playmakers than Purdy himself.
"When you play San Fran, you are thinking about [Christian] McCaffrey, you are thinking about [George] Kittle, you are thinking about [Brandon] Aiyuk," the coordinator explained. "You know Purdy will get it to them, but you are not necessarily thinking about Purdy. You are facing their defense, all these skill guys, Kyle Shanahan."
The coordinator added, "He's a facilitator for them."
Purdy is accustomed to being undervalued—at least when it comes to public perception.
"I've always felt this underdog kind of story," Purdy recently told Richard Sherman. "And that's been my story, from high school, college, to the NFL. But for me, every single year, all that matters is if I'm leading these guys in this locker room, in this building, in this organization, and they trust me here—that's all that matters."
While Purdy has his doubters, one NFL coach expressed frustration with the ongoing criticism surrounding the 49ers quarterback.
"Purdy doesn't get enough credit," the coach told Sando. "The draft is over, OK? The guy has played his ass off. Recognize that! He is not the last pick in the draft anymore. The guy is one win away from being a 1 for some people, if he won a Super Bowl."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Baldy on 49ers QB Brock Purdy: 'He's good enough'
With the San Francisco 49ers' season complete, NFL analyst Brian Baldinger joined Bay Area radio station 95.7 The Game this week to share his assessment of quarterback Brock Purdy. While Baldinger stopped short of placing Purdy among the NFL's elite quarterbacks, he made it... -
49ers legend Steve Young pinpoints two offensive fixes to help Brock Purdy thrive
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy enjoyed a productive 2025 season after returning from a turf toe injury. The team won six straight games following his return before closing the regular season with a Week 18 loss to the Seattle Seahawks. Purdy finished the year... -
PFF: 49ers' Brock Purdy has matched Patrick Mahomes' grade since 2023
Pro Football Focus (PFF) recently evaluated every NFL team's quarterback situation entering the 2026 season, and the San Francisco 49ers were listed among the most stable—largely because of the strength of Brock Purdy's play. In the feature, PFF's John Kosko ranked each... -
Fred Warner: No doubt 49ers will win a Super Bowl with 'elite' Brock Purdy
The San Francisco 49ers have complete confidence in their franchise quarterback, Brock Purdy. Despite having his 2025 season shortened by a turf toe injury, Purdy still delivered strong results, throwing for 2,167 yards with 20 touchdowns and 10 interceptions while leading the...