Shanahan enters his ninth season at the helm in San Francisco. He has led the 49ers to two Super Bowl appearances during his tenure but has yet to secure a championship victory. Last season's disappointing 6-11 finish, fueled by a wave of injuries, played a significant role in his slide down the list.
"Depending on the year, Shanahan's either a schematic genius on the precipice of glory or the dejected face of an injury-ravaged lineup," Benjamin wrote. "No other coach, after all, has guided four NFC title-game appearances in five years, while also overseeing four losing seasons."
San Francisco underwent a major offseason overhaul, aiming to inject youth into what had become an aging roster. The goal is to bounce back in 2025 and set the foundation for future success. Still, the 49ers' playoff hopes hinge heavily on staying healthy. While top-tier talent remains, depth has become a concern.
"It's pretty simple here: If his toys are sturdy, he can draw up a shootout with the best of them," Benjamin added. "Robert Saleh's return as a right-hand man on defense should also help, though Shanahan's also got a conservative bent in the biggest moments."
Between Reid and Shanahan in the rankings are Sean McVay (Rams), John Harbaugh (Ravens), Nick Sirianni (Eagles), Dan Campbell (Lions), and former 49ers coach Jim Harbaugh (Chargers).
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Report: Titans hiring 49ers' Robert Saleh as next head coach
According to multiple reports, the Tennessee Titans are finalizing a deal to hire San Francisco 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh as their next head coach. The Titans conducted an in-person interview with Saleh on Monday as part of the hiring process. The team also... -
Steelers request interview with 49ers OC Klay Kubiak for head coach vacancy
San Francisco 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh continues to draw significant interest from teams searching for a new head coach. Saleh is scheduled to interview with the Miami Dolphins on Thursday night and will speak with the Baltimore Ravens and Tennessee Titans on... -
Titans officially announce ex-49ers coordinator Robert Saleh as head coachÂ
The Tennessee Titans have officially announced former San Francisco 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh as their new head coach. Saleh met with the Titans on Monday, and both sides quickly finalized the deal. It's official. ✍🏽... -
'Last Chance U' coach demands 49ers fire Kyle Shanahan in fiery tirade
The internet personality launched into a profanity-laced tirade on his YouTube show, questioning why the San Francisco 49ers' head coach was not being discussed as a potential firing candidate. After the Buffalo Bills announced they have fired head coach Sean McDermott, Jason...