Aiyuk's contract standoff was the 49ers' top offseason storyline in 2024, and the team ultimately gave in with a massive deal. With the advantage of hindsight, Knox ranked the agreement among the 10 worst contracts in the NFL heading into the 2025 season, coming in at No. 7, suggesting the 49ers were pressured into finalizing the deal as they pushed for another Super Bowl run.
That bet didn't pay off.
The 49ers finished a disappointing 6-11, and Aiyuk played just seven games before suffering season-ending ACL and MCL injuries. Now, with his $30 million-per-year salary—tied with Tyreek Hill for seventh-highest in the NFL, per Over the Cap—his contract is looking like a significant burden on San Francisco's books.
"Aiyuk had flashed high-end potential in his first four seasons," Knox wrote. "He topped 1,000 receiving yards in 2022 and had 1,342 receiving yards in 2023. However, he had yet to establish himself as a top-tier receiver or a perennial Pro Bowler."
While Aiyuk is among the NFL's highest-paid wideouts, Knox doesn't believe he ranks as high when it comes to performance or skill set.
"He showed that by failing to live up to his contract, when healthy, this past season," Knox wrote. "Aiyuk had just 374 yards and no touchdowns in seven games."
Aiyuk isn't even expected to be fully recovered in time for the start of the 49ers' 2025 campaign. There remains uncertainty around how much he'll be able to contribute this year.
"Making this deal even worse is the fact that the 49ers don't have a clean out until 2027, when they can eat $21.2 million in dead money to save $20.2 million in cap space," Knox added.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
John Lynch sets the record straight on 49ers' relationship with Brandon Aiyuk
The Brandon Aiyuk situation took a dramatic turn last week when The Athletic reported that the San Francisco 49ers had voided the wide receiver's guaranteed 2026 salary, a move that signaled a potential split between the team and its player. Head coach Kyle Shanahan later... -
2026 NFL mock draft: 49ers target Brandon Aiyuk replacement with first-round pick
The San Francisco 49ers appear poised to part ways with veteran wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. Aiyuk continues to rehab from the ACL and MCL injuries he sustained in October 2024. The team reportedly grew frustrated with Aiyuk for missing offseason rehab appointments and... -
NFL insider links 49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk to Commanders
San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk may be nearing the end of his tenure in the Bay Area. That became a growing assumption after news broke of the team voiding his 2026 guaranteed salary—a move that still hasn't been fully explained. However, ESPN reported that... -
49ers trade buzz: Fowler breaks down options for Brandon Aiyuk and Mac Jones
The San Francisco 49ers made it easier to move on from injured wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk this offseason by voiding his guaranteed money for 2026—including a $24.9 million option bonus—in July. The Athletic first reported the decision last week, immediately sparking...