However, in identifying each NFL team's Achilles heel, Dalton Wasserman of Pro Football Focus (PFF) named not Mahomes, but Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow as the 49ers' Achilles heel.
That choice may raise some eyebrows. After all, Burrow has only faced the 49ers twice, splitting the series 1-1, with both games occurring during the regular season, far less of an emotional impact than the high-stakes matchups with Mahomes.
So why Burrow? Wasserman's analysis relies on performance metrics, rather than win-loss records or postseason heartbreak. His list highlights the highest-graded player against each team over the past five seasons. And by the numbers, Burrow has quietly dominated in his appearances against San Francisco.
"In two career matchups against San Francisco, Burrow has posted a 91.5 PFF passing grade while throwing five touchdowns and no interceptions," Wasserman noted. "He also produced eight big-time throws compared to two turnover-worthy plays in those games."
In addition to his five touchdowns against the 49ers, Burrow has completed 53 of his 66 pass attempts for 631 yards against San Francisco's defense.
Still, while the analytics data may favor Burrow, many 49ers fans would argue that Mahomes, who boasts two Super Bowl wins over San Francisco, remains the more painful thorn in the team's side.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Fred Warner earns No. 1 PFF ranking despite injury-shortened season
The San Francisco 49ers had hoped to get Fred Warner back for the NFC Championship Game, believing their defensive leader could help power another Super Bowl run. Unfortunately, fans never got to see the All-Pro linebacker return to the field this past season. Warner suffered... -
PFF names 49ers' best-case scenario in Round 1 of 2026 NFL Draft
With the NFL Scouting Combine in the books, mock drafts continue to shape narratives ahead of the 2026 NFL Draft. The San Francisco 49ers, who have multiple offseason needs, are already being linked to several first-round possibilities. John Kosko of Pro Football Focus (PFF)... -
PFF names 49ers' Upton Stout one of the NFL's worst slot corners
The transition from college football to the NFL is rarely seamless, particularly for defensive backs tasked with handling some of the league's most dynamic route-runners who generally operate from the slot. For San Francisco 49ers rookie cornerback Upton Stout, that reality... -
49ers Must Avoid a Costly Trent Williams Mistake—And One Draft Pick May Be the Answer
In 2006, the Pittsburgh Steelers released linebacker/edge rusher Joey Porter rather than pay him a large roster bonus. For years, Porter had been the star of the defense, a four-time Pro Bowler and a first-team All-Pro. At the time, I thought they were crazy. Why would they do...