The 49ers famously traded a significant package of draft capital to select quarterback Trey Lance at No. 3 overall in 2021, and their top pick in 2020, defensive tackle Javon Kinlaw, never met expectations. Neither player remains on the roster.
Now, all eyes are on their latest first-round selection, former Georgia defensive end Mykel Williams. San Francisco can't afford another high-profile miss. Yet, Manzano believes Williams could be a bust (h/t Grant Cohn of Sports Illustrated for the find).
"The 49ers have struggled to find a productive No. 2 edge rusher to complement Nick Bosa," Manzano explained. "It's tough to assess whether San Francisco finally found the right player to hold down the role for many years to come partly because Williams didn't have the breakout junior season many expected him to have at Georgia due to a nagging ankle injury.
"Still, Williams displayed plenty of toughness and leaned on his superior strength to shed off blockers and create pressure. But the No. 11 pick might not have the same upside as the edge rushers who went after him. Walker is more polished and has positional versatility."
Interestingly, Manzano refers to Williams' former Georgia teammate, Jalon Walker, as the more polished option, yet also includes Walker in his list of five potential busts.
"For this year's potential busts, the focus was more on the team's poor track record at certain positions," Manzano wrote. "Also, versatility can be a negative if a team doesn't know how to apply it."
Manzano also notes that former Tennessee standout James Pearce Jr. was likely the best athlete among this year's pass rushers and even argues that former Texas A&M defender Shemar Stewart has more athletic upside than Williams. However, Manzano acknowledges there's bust potential with the latter as well.
Still, labeling any player a bust before their first NFL snap feels premature, and Manzano even states that in his article. General manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan were reportedly surprised—and thrilled—to see Williams still available when they were on the clock at No. 11. The 49ers even tried to trade up to secure him.
"If Williams can develop more tools and rely more on skills to break free, then adding the Georgia product to this list could look silly by next draft season," Manzano concluded.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' De'Zhaun Stribling named among rookies with Pro Bowl, All-Pro potential in 2026
There was no shortage of analysts who questioned the San Francisco 49ers' decision to draft wide receiver De'Zhaun Stribling with the No. 33 overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Many believed the selection to be a reach. However, one NFL writer believes the rookie could quickly... -
49ers rookie Kaelon Black confident in dual-threat potential after minicamp debut
New San Francisco 49ers running back Kaelon Black is already making his case as a versatile offensive weapon after showcasing his receiving ability early during his college career. At James Madison, Black flashed strong dual-threat potential with 44 receptions for 431 yards... -
Former 49ers safety urges position change for 4th-round draft pick
The San Francisco 49ers appear to have strengthened their secondary with the selection of former Washington and Arizona cornerback Ephesians Prysock in the fourth round of the 2026 NFL Draft. At just over 6-foot-3 with a 6-foot-8½ wingspan, Prysock brings rare size to... -
2026 Draft Aftermath: Is the 49ers' Rejection of the Consensus Draft Board Really a Mistake?
There's an old Irish proverb that says, "Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups." This declaration could apply to many areas of our culture, especially politics and government. And it sometimes applies well to sports. The public outrage over the 49ers'...