San Francisco is working on a contract extension for their fourth-year quarterback, who previously helped guide the team to two NFC Championship Games and a Super Bowl appearance. Purdy's value has been a subject of heavy debate and remains central to the ongoing negotiations.
Recently, when asked if he considers Purdy a top-10 quarterback, team owner Jed York responded, "I think he is. I think he's great."
However, he added a caveat.
"Especially when you combine him with [head coach] Kyle [Shanahan] and you combine him with what we have," York explained.
That comment has sparked discussion, with some interpreting it as York suggesting a significant portion of Purdy's success is due to Shanahan's offensive system and the talent surrounding him—an argument often used by Purdy's harshest critics.
According to The Athletic's Dianna Russini, no teams have inquired about Purdy, which she suggests might indicate how the league views the quarterback outside Shanahan's scheme.
"There have not been any teams that have called the San Francisco 49ers to trade for Brock Purdy," Russini said on her podcast, The Scoop. "So that kind of tells you how the rest of the league views him without Kyle Shanahan, perhaps."
Of course, it's also possible teams haven't called because the 49ers have clarified that extending Purdy is a top priority. San Francisco has offloaded significant future cash spending, signaling an expectation that a sizable portion of the salary cap will be allocated to one player—Purdy.
Still, Russini raises the question: "If he is a top-10 quarterback, truly, outside, with Kyle detached from it, how come no teams have called to trade for him?"
She also speculates that Purdy's eventual deal could average around $52 million annually, placing him among the top 10 highest-paid players in the league.
"And remember, too," Russini added, "before they traded three first-round picks for Trey Lance, they wanted Mac Jones. Guess who's on this roster? Mac Jones."
H/t to Grant Cohn of Sports Illustrated for the find.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
NFL insider: 49ers could lose top assistant after Raheem Morris hire
The San Francisco 49ers reportedly found their new defensive coordinator on Sunday, hiring former Atlanta Falcons head coach Raheem Morris. The team also interviewed two other candidates: 49ers assistant head coach Gus Bradley and Las Vegas Raiders pass game coordinator and... -
49ers' Fred Warner settles the debate: Where does Brock Purdy rank among NFL QBs?
The debate over where Brock Purdy ranks among the NFL's elite passers remains a hot topic. However, for San Francisco 49ers All-Pro linebacker Fred Warner, there is no debate—Purdy is the gold standard in the league. "I think that he just processes the game at a different... -
49ers' Brock Purdy shares honest perspective on 2025 performance
The 2025 season didn't unfold the way San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy had envisioned. Fresh off a massive contract extension, Purdy entered the year motivated to justify the organization's belief in him and build on his previous success. The season began on a... -
49ers, Kyle Shanahan lose another top assistant to Titans
As expected, the Tennessee Titans have made a move to hire San Francisco 49ers assistant head coach Gus Bradley, bringing him on as their new defensive coordinator. Titans are hiring 49ers assistant head coach Gus Bradley as their defensive coordinator, per source....