Has Purdy's performance this season lowered his market value? Will he settle for less than top-tier quarterback money, or will he aim for a contract exceeding $60 million annually? Such a figure would significantly strain the 49ers' ability to spend elsewhere, jeopardizing the abundance of talent that has supported Purdy's success over the past three seasons.
"Purdy is a fascinating case study for NFL teams' comfort levels paying top dollar to quarterbacks who are very good but outside the elite group," wrote Jeremy Fowler in a feature for ESPN.
The NFL insider highlights that the 49ers are willing to engage in tough negotiations, citing last season's contract dealings with wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk as an example. However, drawn-out talks with Purdy's camp would be risky. The team likely hopes to avoid the lingering issues that affected Aiyuk's early-season performance after prolonged negotiations.
But what happens if talks with Purdy go south? Fowler presents a dramatic contingency plan: the potential acquisition of a veteran quarterback. And no, it's not Kirk Cousins of the Atlanta Falcons.
"And if for some reason things go poorly and the 49ers need contingency plans, I can think of one quarterback who is playing for a lot: New York's Aaron Rodgers," Fowler wrote. "What's interesting about Rodgers is he could finish with 4,000 yards and close to 30 touchdowns on the season. Not bad, amid all that has gone wrong."
Given how poorly Rodgers' tenure with the Jets has gone, many fans likely view the 49ers taking a chance on the polarizing quarterback as unlikely.
Fowler's ESPN colleague, Dan Graziano, weighed in on the possibility.
"I've covered this league long enough to know that GMs and team owners do objectively damaging things to their franchises all the time when they absolutely should know better," Graziano wrote. "So while I can't even conceive of one mildly decent reason for a team to turn to Rodgers in 2025 after the way things have gone for him with the Jets, I acknowledge the possibility that some team might."
Purdy's contract negotiations are shaping into one of the most compelling offseason storylines. General manager John Lynch and the 49ers' front office face a critical decision: determining Purdy's value and solidifying the quarterback position for the foreseeable future without jeopardizing the team's ability to compete.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
NFL insider: 49ers could lose top assistant after Raheem Morris hire
The San Francisco 49ers reportedly found their new defensive coordinator on Sunday, hiring former Atlanta Falcons head coach Raheem Morris. The team also interviewed two other candidates: 49ers assistant head coach Gus Bradley and Las Vegas Raiders pass game coordinator and... -
NFL insider believes 49ers will have interest in Jim Schwartz for defensive coordinator
The San Francisco 49ers' search for a new defensive coordinator has remained relatively quiet. The only known detail so far is that assistant head coach Gus Bradley is viewed as the top internal candidate—a logical option given his familiarity with the defensive scheme.... -
NFL insider speculates on why the 49ers passed on signing Cooper Kupp
Cooper Kupp is headed to his second Super Bowl, set to be played between the Seattle Seahawks and the New England Patriots at Levi's Stadium. Meanwhile, the San Francisco 49ers could have used additional help at wide receiver this season amid the ongoing drama surrounding... -
NFL insider predicts 49ers could trade Mac Jones to this NFC team
San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan indicated last week that he expects backup quarterback Mac Jones to remain with the team during the 2026 season. Despite that stance, trade speculation continues to follow the former first-round pick after his extended playing time...