Hall of Fame quarterback Steve Young joined Bay Area radio station KNBR on Wednesday, suggesting that McCaffrey's return could be essential to the 49ers rediscovering their identity after a 4-4 start.
McCaffrey has not played this season, landing on injured reserve due to Achilles tendinitis. Young argued that keeping the star running back healthy should be the 49ers' top priority moving forward.
When asked about the keys to the 49ers' success, Young responded, "Christian McCaffrey healthy for the second half of the season. That's number one, two and three. Now, number four is protection, making sure that when we run into the teams that can rush four and put you in a bind, that our five guys have got to answer. And I would say that we need to prove that. That would be the fourth thing. The first three things are Christian McCaffrey and then that one."
Young noted that adding a playmaker in a trade may not ultimately solve the team's woes. While an addition could help bolster the roster, he notes that bringing in a player who could disrupt the team's chemistry is also easy.
"I don't want someone to come and get in the way," Young cautioned. "But defensively, it doesn't look like we're going to be a defensive front that's going to just bring four [rushers] and just cause all kinds of grief.
"We know we can pinch with [DE Leonard] Floyd and [DE] Nick [Bosa], and that's not going to go away, and it will always be an important part of what we get done, but we can't push. And so, we're not going to dominate from the defensive line."
Young hinted that the 49ers might be in a transition phase. Head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch have typically focused on building a strong defensive front, sometimes at the expense of other areas. However, with the secondary emerging as a strength, there could be an unexpected shift.
"I've gotta admit, everyone's pretty excited about the secondary," Young said. "I am, too. I kind of like watching them."
Young also praised George Kittle's standout performance against the Cowboys, where the tight end recorded 128 receiving yards and a touchdown on six catches. Young believes the team needs consistent standout performances like this, especially with wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk out for the season. Success may even come from a rotating cast of playmakers each week.
"This year, with not everybody [healthy], we need George Kittle to be Player of the Month," Young emphasized. "CMC's (McCaffrey) got to be Player of the Month. [WR] Deebo's [Samuel] got to be Player of the Month. If we're going to go the distance, that's what's got to come."
You can listen to Young's entire interview below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers great Steve Young doesn't mince words on 'terrible' Brandon Aiyuk drama
As if the injury-plagued 2025 campaign weren't difficult enough, the San Francisco 49ers are now navigating a troubling Brandon Aiyuk situation. The wide receiver continues to rehab from the ACL and MCL injuries he suffered last season. While there was once optimism he could... -
Steve Young: 49ers are 'good enough to threaten' in the playoffs
How good are the San Francisco 49ers really? Heading into their Week 14 bye, they have nine wins—the same number as the Chicago Bears and Los Angeles Rams, the two teams that would occupy the top seeds in the NFC if the season ended today. At 9-4, the 49ers are currently... -
49ers Keys to Victory: How San Francisco Can Beat the Browns on the Road in Week 13
The San Francisco 49ers travel to Cleveland in an NFC West versus an AFC North matchup on Sunday. The 8-4 Niners look to add to their two-game win streak against the Browns. If the 49ers are looking to improve to 9-4 heading into their bye week, they must stick to the Keys to... -
49ers' Week 16 opponent loses starting quarterback
The Jacksonville Jaguars defeated the Indianapolis Colts 36-19 on Sunday, further dimming Indy's playoff hopes. A significant setback compounded the loss—quarterback Daniel Jones is out for the season after suffering a torn Achilles during the Week 14 defeat. Jones had...