The sheer numbers at the position have led to speculation that Mason—or even Mitchell—might be the odd man out. Joe Tansey of Bleacher Report named both running backs as potential 49ers trade candidates, a three-person list that includes wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk.
Mitchell had an impressive 2021 rookie campaign, rushing for 963 yards. However, he failed to surpass the 300-yard mark in his last two seasons, with his average yards per carry falling to 3.7 last season. Injuries and the arrival of McCaffrey, who tends to fight to stay on the football field, have limited Mitchell's opportunities and contributed to his disappointing numbers.
Tansey believes the addition of Guerendo could threaten Mitchell's standing with the 49ers, suggesting that one of the veteran running backs might have to go.
"Mitchell's two sub-300-yard seasons might not intrigue some teams, but he has previous responsibility as the top guy and averaged over 4.5 yards per carry in two of his three NFL seasons," Tansey wrote.
"Guerendo and Jordan Mason can be good insurance policies for McCaffrey if Mitchell moves on. Any market for Mitchell would likely develop once training camp begins. One injury could change the entire running back market."
Regarding Mason, Tansey believes the third-year running back is in even more danger of departure. While he only has 464 career rushing yards, he has averaged an impressive 5.6 yards per attempt, making him an intriguing prospect for teams looking to bolster their running back rooms.
Potentially becoming the fourth running back on the depth chart makes Mason's future uncertain.
"Mason may be better off signing with another team after a potential release, but the 49ers could get a late Day 3 pick for him if a team is that interested in him," Tansey remarked.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers Notebook: Jordan Watkins steps up for injured WRs; Kaelon Black's mostly positive performance; What happened on Brock Purdy's INTs?
The San Francisco 49ers may have seen their six-game winning streak come to an end on Sunday, but one poor performance wasn't enough to completely dampen the spirits of the team as they head into their bye week. After taking a 14-3 lead over the Falcons at Mercedes-Benz... -
What 49ers' Kyle Juszczyk told Kaelon Black, Jordan James after fumbles
The San Francisco 49ers appeared to be building momentum late in the second quarter against the Atlanta Falcons on Sunday, holding a 14-9 lead. However, two consecutive fumbles by young running backs Jordan James and Kaelon Black disrupted the drive and allowed Atlanta to close... -
49ers' Jordan Watkins gets strong vote of confidence from Klay Kubiak, Brock Purdy
Second-year San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Jordan Watkins has just three catches this season, including one on his only target Monday night against the Washington Commanders, despite playing 47 offensive snaps. He caught his other two passes in Week 3 against the Arizona... -
49ers Trade: Are Mack, Sweat, Thomas Jr. or Wilson Next?
John Lynch brought DeForest Buckner back to San Francisco for a 2027 fourth-round pick, adding a proven starter to a defensive line that needed help generating consistent pressure. With the November 10 trade deadline approaching, Lynch could still make another move, especially...