Gordon McGuinness isn't convinced. The Pro Football Focus analyst examined one potential offseason move for each NFC team that can improve its roster, and upon reviewing the 49ers' roster, suggests that adding a veteran guard might be necessary.
"Dominick Puni can be a day-one starter at right guard for the 49ers as a third-round draft pick out of Kansas, but they could still stand to improve on the opposite side," McGuinness wrote. "Aaron Banks earned just a 50.2 PFF pass-blocking grade last season and struggled in the Super Bowl loss to the Kansas City Chiefs. This is a spot where Dalton Risner or Greg Van Roten could compete for a starting job."
Although the 49ers have consistently voiced confidence in Banks, the former second-round draft pick has never received high marks from Pro Football Focus. While his 52.8 overall grade from the analytics site last season is a career low, it's not significantly lower than his career high, a 59.5 grade earned in 2022.
Much is made of Colton McKivitz's inconsistent play at right tackle, but Banks benefits from playing next to one of the best in the game, left tackle Trent Williams. However, it's noteworthy that while Banks allowed 36 pressures last season, including the playoffs, he didn't concede a single sack in his 597 pass-blocking snaps.
Banks is set to become a free agent next year and could be a candidate for a contract extension. Nonetheless, McGuinness believes the 49ers can do better.
Risner didn't allow a sack in his 485 pass-blocking snaps with the Minnesota Vikings last season. An in-season signing, Risner was named the Vikings' starting left guard in Week 7. McGuinness recently noted that the offensive lineman remains "a starting-caliber guard in the NFL."
"His 67.4 PFF pass-blocking grade in 2023 marked the fifth straight season where he earned a PFF pass-blocking grade above 65.0, with 30 total pressures allowed from 485 pass-blocking snaps," wrote McGuinness.
While Van Roten allowed five sacks with the Las Vegas Raiders in 2023, his 77.4 pass-blocking grade surpasses Banks' or Risner's, likely benefiting from allowing only 21 pressures.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers offensive line rankings: How PFF graded San Francisco's starters in 2025
The San Francisco 49ers' offensive line remains one of the most debated topics among fans heading into the 2026 offseason. While head coach Kyle Shanahan has consistently defended the team's approach to building the unit, frustration continues to grow over the perceived lack of... -
Where 49ers RB Christian McCaffrey landed in PFF's top 101 players of 2025
After injuries limited him to just four games in 2024, San Francisco 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey fell off Pro Football Focus' (PFF) Top 101 list. He ensured the absence was short-lived. McCaffrey rebounded in 2025 with a dominant, full 17-game campaign, totaling... -
Where 49ers QB Brock Purdy landed in PFF's top 101 players of 2025
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy appeared in just nine games during the 2025 NFL season, missing eight contests due to a turf toe injury suffered in Week 1. Still, the former final pick of the 2022 NFL Draft did more than enough to earn recognition from Pro Football... -
Where 49ers OT Colton McKivitz landed in PFF's top 101 players of 2025
What a difference a season made for San Francisco 49ers right tackle Colton McKivitz. The veteran offensive lineman made his debut on Pro Football Focus' (PFF) list of the top 101 players of the 2025 NFL season, checking in at No. 63 — notably ahead of quarterback Brock...