It's also difficult to pay everyone, and Miller knows that. It's not a formula for successful roster building, including paying two wide receivers top dollar.
The 49ers are trying to negotiate a contract extension with wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. The team invested heavily in another receiver, Deebo Samuel, just two years ago. Is allowing each of them to consume a significant chunk of the salary cap feasible for a team that hopes to continue being competitive and win Super Bowls?
"I have to separate the fan part of my brain, who doesn't want to see him (Aiyuk) leave, from the team-building part of my brain, the analytical part," Miller told Al Sacco on the 49ers Webzone "No Huddle" podcast. "I wouldn't pay him. I wouldn't.
"Now, I will say this: I would have paid Aiyuk before I paid Deebo. And I understand, at the time, that would have been a hot take. But as much as I love Deebo, he's been banged up since college. It's just his play style. He takes a lot of punishment. So at the time, I thought Aiyuk was a better long-term play just because of play style."
Miller notes that the 49ers seemingly made their choice in 2022. While he would hate to see either player with another team, it's difficult to imagine San Francisco investing that much money into just two players.
"If you had a year one rookie quarterback, you could afford to do it and make it work," Miller added. "I think it gets a little bit harder now that Brock [Purdy] has some years under his belt. You're going to have to pay him, and you're trying to forecast that out."
Several 49ers players, including defensive end Nick Bosa and running back Christian McCaffrey, are already earning the most money at their positions. Trent Williams is among the top-paid offensive linemen in the NFL.
"It's like, something's got to give," Miller said. "And I think wide receiver is one of those positions where you can get immediate impact from a rookie. There's guys, first round, second round, third round, who come in and are great players ... So I think that's where it would suck to see Brandon Aiyuk playing for another team, but you have to understand, that's how teams are built in this day and age.
"You get a young quarterback, and you support him. And when that young quarterback elevates, it's his turn to support the players around him. And that's where San Francisco's at in that timeline right now."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' John Lynch addresses futures of Brandon Aiyuk and Mac Jones
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch joined The TK Show with Tim Kawakami and discussed the futures of two key players—Brandon Aiyuk and Mac Jones. Recent reporting revealed that the 49ers voided Aiyuk's guaranteed money for 2026, a move many viewed as signaling an... -
49ers' John Lynch on Brandon Aiyuk's status: "Nothing to add there"
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch joined Bay Area radio station KNBR on Thursday and was asked for an update on wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. His response was brief—there is no update. "Nothing to add there," Lynch said. "We've talked about that ad nauseam.... -
NFL insider links 49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk to Commanders
San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk may be nearing the end of his tenure in the Bay Area. That became a growing assumption after news broke of the team voiding his 2026 guaranteed salary—a move that still hasn't been fully explained. However, ESPN reported that... -
49ers great Steve Young doesn't mince words on 'terrible' Brandon Aiyuk drama
As if the injury-plagued 2025 campaign weren't difficult enough, the San Francisco 49ers are now navigating a troubling Brandon Aiyuk situation. The wide receiver continues to rehab from the ACL and MCL injuries he suffered last season. While there was once optimism he could...