During a recent conversation on the "Pardon My Take" podcast, Schefter discussed the 49ers' lack of interest in adding a rookie quarterback in 2017, including future Hall of Famer Patrick Mahomes, despite initially owning the No. 2 overall pick. What led the 49ers to avoid thoroughly evaluating quarterbacks from that draft class? Head coach Kyle Shanahan believed the team could secure Kirk Cousins the following offseason.
However, Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots blew up Shanahan's plans by offering Jimmy Garoppolo, which the 49ers accepted.
San Francisco did end up drafting a quarterback in 2017—C.J. Beathard. He remained with the 49ers throughout his rookie contract before departing via free agency for the Jacksonville Jaguars in 2021. As a result, the 49ers received a compensatory pick the following year—the last overall pick in 2022.
You can listen to Schefter recounting the story in the social media post below.
Again, Schefter isn't revealing anything groundbreaking. However, it remains an interesting story of how a single decision in the NFL can have ripple effects five years later, ultimately leading the 49ers to their (hopefully) quarterback of the future despite initially dismissing Mahomes and others.
In 2021, a year before drafting Purdy, Shanahan reflected on passing on Mahomes.
"Anybody who had a chance to take Patrick Mahomes or Deshaun (Watson) who didn't, I mean, everyone wishes we had a time machine," Shanahan said. "Before I came here, I had a very good idea that we would be able to get a free-agent quarterback (Cousins) the next year, one that I knew we could win with. So you're looking at these rookies … and no one at that time was considering those guys top-five picks, top-ten picks."
Instead, the 49ers didn't land Cousins and Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs have denied Shanahan two Super Bowl championships, with the most recent setback occurring 19 days ago in Las Vegas.
Shanahan concluded, "Hell yeah, I wish I could go back and have Patrick Mahomes or Deshaun. I think every other coach on the planet feels the same."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers QB Brock Purdy '100 percent' confident team can win Super Bowl next season
Despite his team looking like anything other than a Super Bowl contender in their 41-6 Divisional Round playoff loss to the Seattle Seahawks on Saturday night, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy seems extremely high on his team's chances as they head into 2026. Purdy... -
49ers' Kyle Shanahan explains Brock Purdy's remarkable success in Seattle
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy earned his first career road start in 2022 with a 21-13 win over the Seattle Seahawks at Lumen Field. Since then, he has played three additional games in one of the loudest and most challenging environments in the NFL — and won all... -
Brock Purdy, 49ers embrace underdog role ahead of Seahawks playoff clash
The Seattle Seahawks enter Saturday's Divisional Round playoff game as seven-point favorites against the San Francisco 49ers. But the Niners have already shown that being labeled an underdog doesn't faze them. Last week in Philadelphia, San Francisco overcame the odds,... -
49ers Notebook: Purdy reflects on tough season; Jennings talks future; Kittle, Warner, and Williams recovery timelines
Monday marked the final opportunity for reporters to speak with San Francisco 49ers players at the team's facilities until the offseason program begins. The 49ers' injury-plagued 2025 season came to a disappointing end over the weekend with a playoff loss to division rival...