Even head coach Kyle Shanahan was reluctant to take a side, not wanting to get in trouble for campaigning for one or the other.
"That's the only reason I wouldn't overly comment on either one of them because I don't want them to cancel each other out," Shanahan said last week. "But if any non-quarterback is going to get an MVP, I don't get how Christian McCaffrey can't. I mean, he's amazing in what he's done all year.
"If it's going to a quarterback, then I don't have to talk about Christian. I can talk about our quarterback. And if his numbers is all you see, then I think that solves it up. But if you watch the film, then it makes it even stronger, which to me is the most important thing."
NFL legend and Bay Area icon Jerry Rice recently joined 49ers linebacker Fred Warner's podcast, "The Warner House," and was asked who should win the coveted award. The Hall of Fame wide receiver couldn't pick a side either.
"I think both guys," Rice declared. "... It's amazing because you see how valuable CMC (McCaffrey) is if he's not in the game, and also, Brock Purdy. We always talk about that missing piece and you have to be also part of a chain. And if you're a weak link in that chain, you're not going to have success, you're not going to win football games, you're not going to win championships.
"I don't see us winning a championship without Brock Purdy. I don't see us winning a championship without CMC. So, I don't know how this is going to unfold, but I think both guys really deserve that."
Warner suggested splitting the trophy in half, with each player taking home the honor. You probably wouldn't get any argument from Purdy or McCaffrey on that idea.
Rice continued praising the two players, saying, "I'm going to go back to Brock one more time because Brock reminds me a lot of [QB Joe] Montana, his coolness. He doesn't get rattled, and you need your quarterback to be that way. And with CMC, coming out of the backfield, catching the ball, rushing, scoring touchdowns, he does it all."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Christian McCaffrey among nominees for FedEx Air & Ground NFL Players of the Year
The NFL announced today that nominees for the FedEx Air & Ground NFL Players of the Year are: Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen finished the season with 3,668 passing yards and 25 touchdown passes. He ranked first among quarterbacks in rushing touchdowns (14) and... -
ESPN questions whether 49ers RB Christian McCaffrey's impact is being overhyped
From a raw production standpoint, San Francisco 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey delivered another eye-catching season. He finished just 76 receiving yards shy of becoming the first player in NFL history to post multiple seasons with 1,000 rushing yards and 1,000... -
Saquon Barkley praises 49ers RB Christian McCaffrey: 'He's one of the best to ever do it'
Saquon Barkley will aim to run over the San Francisco 49ers defense on Sunday, hoping to help his Philadelphia Eagles advance to the Divisional Round of the playoffs. His counterpart, 49ers star running back Christian McCaffrey, will look to do the same. Though they'll be... -
49ers' Week 18 loss to Seahawks: Key stats, records, and McCaffrey milestones
The San Francisco 49ers finished their 2025 season with a 12-5 record thanks to a 13-3 Week 18 loss to the Seattle Seahawks at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, California. Below are several statistics and notes from Saturday's game, which were provided by the 49ers...