Baldinger has the 49ers going 12-5 during the upcoming season. So where did the two analysts disagree? Brooks could not believe his colleague had San Francisco falling to the Washington Commanders in Week 17.
"It's an East Coast game, Bucky," Baldinger explained on NFL Network's Total Access. "Their biorhythms are off, but I think they finish with a win [against the Los Angeles Rams] and with a 12-5 record. I don't know if that's a No. 1 seed or not, but it's a high seed. They'll be ready for the playoffs."
For his own prediction, Brooks changed the game against Washington to a 49ers win.
"I can't go with you on that one," Brooks said. "I can't give you the Commanders game."
Brooks also changed a loss against the Cleveland Browns to a win.
"I think they go 14-3," Brooks added.
San Francisco is expected again to boast one of the league's top defenses. The unit finished as the best in the NFL in 2022 and poached a top defender from an NFC competitor, adding former Philadelphia Eagles defensive tackle Javon Hargrave. He joins a front that already included the NFL Defensive Player of the Year, Nick Bosa, and Arik Armstead.
As is often the case, offseason uncertainty surrounds the quarterback position. Brock Purdy was a rookie sensation last season, guiding the 49ers to the NFC Championship Game before suffering a tear of the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) in his right elbow. He underwent surgery on March 10 and will miss most—if not all—of the offseason. Trey Lance and Sam Darnold will compete to start Week 1 in case Purdy isn't medically cleared by then.
Below is a rundown of Baldinger's and Brooks' 2023 game-by-game predictions for the 49ers.
| Baldinger | Brooks | |
| at Steelers | L | L |
| at Rams | W | W |
| Giants | W | W |
| Cardinals | W | W |
| Cowboys | W | W |
| at Browns | L | W |
| at Vikings | W | W |
| Bengals | W | W |
| at Jaguars | W | W |
| Buccaneers | W | W |
| at Seahawks | W | W |
| at Eagles | L | L |
| Seahawks | L | L |
| at Cardinals | W | W |
| Ravens | W | W |
| at Commanders | L | W |
| Rams | W | W |
| Record | 12-5 | 14-3 |
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Bucky Brooks: Why the Eagles are the 49ers' best playoff matchup
While many view the Philadelphia Eagles as one of the toughest possible playoff matchups for the San Francisco 49ers, NFL analyst Bucky Brooks sees it differently. In fact, Brooks believes the Eagles may be the best matchup the 49ers could have drawn and explained why during a... -
49ers vs. Seahawks injury report: Fred Warner practices, other updates
The San Francisco 49ers are preparing for their Divisional Round playoff contest against the Seattle Seahawks on Saturday at Lumen Field in Seattle, Washington. Safety Marques Sigle appears to be trending toward a starting role this weekend for the 49ers. Ji'Ayir Brown, who... -
Loss of George Kittle latest heartbreaker in 49ers' injury-plagued season
Just how much must San Francisco 49ers fans endure this season? The sight of All-Pro tight end George Kittle making a catch, going down near the sideline, and immediately grabbing his leg was the latest gut punch for the 49ers in what has been a brutal, injury-plagued 2025... -
49ers vs. Eagles injury updates: George Kittle suffers Achilles injury
The San Francisco 49ers are facing the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field in a Wild Card playoff game. Below are the latest in-game injury updates for the 49ers. This article will be updated in real time as new information becomes available. Players are listed in...