OverTheCap.com projects Kinlaw's fifth-year option to cost about $10.5 million, all of which would be guaranteed. That's a lot of money for a player who has spent a good chunk of his career injured and hasn't been able to reach expectations while on the football field.
"The team is unlikely to pick up his fifth-year option in May, which means he's heading into the final year of his contract," wrote Matt Barrows of The Athletic. "Kinlaw played just three games last season before his knee began acting up, and the 49ers have to consider a more dependable starting defensive tackle."
Of course, this sounds more like speculation than an actual report, but the logic behind the assumption makes sense.
Kinlaw, 25, recorded four tackles through six starts with the 49ers last season. He has just 1.5 career sacks, all of which came during his rookie 2020 campaign.
The defensive tackle's best overall single-season Pro Football Focus grade of the season was 58.7, which came in Week 2. He earned a mark of 44.2-or-lower in each of his final four games, including the playoffs. Kinlaw's 31.9 overall grade and 28.8 run-defense grade this past season are career lows.
Kinlaw missed 11 games this past season after issues arose with his surgically repaired knee. He has missed 24 regular-season games over the past two seasons.
"Even after returning in mid-December, his snap counts were restricted and he never seemed to be at top form," Barrows wrote. "Kinlaw was shoved around by the Eagles' interior offensive linemen in the NFC Championship Game and he ended the season with the lowest run grade of any 49ers defender, 28.8, according to Pro Football Focus."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Mykel Williams among NFL's second-year players facing the most pressure
For the San Francisco 49ers, the defensive front was once a strength of the team, consistently disrupting opposing quarterbacks and overwhelming offensive lines. That wasn't the case last season, however, as the unit recorded just 20 sacks—the fewest in the NFL. Determined... -
49ers' Fred Warner tops ESPN's off-ball linebacker rankings despite coming off injury
San Francisco 49ers linebacker Fred Warner remains one of the NFL's most respected defensive players. Although he missed 11 games last season after suffering a dislocated and fractured right ankle, the All-Pro linebacker still earned the top spot in a prominent offseason... -
49ers QB Brock Purdy lands surprising spot in 2026 fantasy football rankings
Where does San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy rank among the NFL's top fantasy football quarterbacks entering the 2026 season? NFL Media's Dan Parr released his fantasy football quarterback rankings for NFL.com, organizing the league's top signal-callers into draft... -
49ers' Brock Purdy left out of ESPN's top-10 quarterback rankings
The debate over where San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy ranks among the NFL's elite continues. ESPN's Jeremy Fowler continued his annual NFL position rankings this week, unveiling his list of the league's top quarterbacks. The rankings are based on feedback from NFL...