The Niners attempted to trade Garoppolo in March, but all discussions halted when the quarterback surprised the team and opted to undergo shoulder surgery. That delayed things, which reduced the 49ers' options. As Garoppolo recovered, the list of quarterback-needy teams shrunk.
49ers general manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan have tried to convince everyone that they are willing, if necessary, to hold onto Garoppolo in 2022 if a suitable offer doesn't present itself. That certainly isn't Plan A, though. Instead, once the quarterback is healthy, they hope to try to reignite conversations with other teams.
"Nothing's changed since his surgery," Shanahan told reporters in May. "You know where we were at before that, and then he got surgery, so everything went on hold. I expect him, at some time, most likely, to be traded, but who knows? That's not a guarantee, and it's been on hold [since] that happened."
Maiocco can't envision the 49ers holding onto Garoppolo due to the quarterback's heft salary.
"I think that the least likely [scenario], in my mind, would be to take on that $25 million, keep him on the team, and then what role?" Maiocco said on KNBR (h/t KNBR staff).
It would not make much sense to pay Garoppolo that much money to be second-year quarterback Trey Lance's backup. And if he isn't viewed as a backup and actually competes for the starting job, the national media would be quick to criticize the 49ers' plan for Lance.
"When we talked to him ... after the season, I mean, he said goodbye to everybody," Maiocco continued. "And I think he kind of finished that call with, 'Yeah, it's been a great ride.' So in his mind, he already had both feet out the door. So it's just crazy to think ... I just can't see him, right now, being a starting quarterback for any team the first week of the season."
That's not to say that Maiocco doesn't believe Garoppolo is a starting-caliber player. He does.
"I would say, clearly, he's one of the top 25 quarterbacks in the league," Maiocco clarified, "if not just a little bit better than that. So theoretically, he should be starting for a team, but most of the teams [are settled at quarterback]."
While some teams might look into acquiring Garoppolo should the 49ers release the veteran quarterback—like the Seattle Seahawks and Carolina Panthers—Maiocco named one other option that makes the most sense.
"The one team that could potentially win this year [with Garoppolo] is Cleveland," Maiocco said, "but they're probably not going to win too much with Deshaun Watson on the suspended list and with Baker Mayfield on some beach somewhere."
You can listen to the entire conversation with Maiocco below.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers insider identifies two potential salary-cap cut candidates
As NFL teams begin evaluating their rosters ahead of the 2026 offseason, The Athletic asked its staff to identify potential salary-cap cut candidates for each franchise. For the San Francisco 49ers, beat writer Matt Barrows pointed to two names worth monitoring. Barrows... -
49ers draft buzz: Daniel Jeremiah identifies pass rushers, WR targets for San Francisco
With the 2026 NFL Draft approaching, Daniel Jeremiah offered insight into how the San Francisco 49ers could address two of their most pressing offseason needs: pass rusher and wide receiver. The longtime NFL Draft analyst held his annual pre-Combine conference call ahead of... -
NFL insider: 49ers expected to have interest in Mike Evans
The San Francisco 49ers are expected to be among the teams with interest in veteran wide receiver Mike Evans when NFL free agency opens in the coming weeks. Evans is set to hit the open market after 12 seasons with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, potentially ending one of the most... -
Trade or release? 49ers insider weighs in on Brandon Aiyuk's future
The San Francisco 49ers appear headed for a split with wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. Whether that separation comes via trade or release remains unclear, but one thing seems certain: Aiyuk's time in red and gold is likely over. "I think it's safe to say that he's played his last...