Jared Goff clearly wasn't going to do that, so McVay and the Rams went all-in last offseason to acquire Stafford from the Lions. Kyle Shanahan and the San Francisco 49ers were interested too but got beat to the punch.
"That was frustrating," Shanahan admitted last year. "... I was trying to get involved in it."
Could San Francisco have won it all with Stafford at the helm instead of Garoppolo? Maybe. They made it to the NFC Championship Game with Garoppolo fighting through thumb and shoulder injuries before being eliminated by Stafford and the Rams.
Los Angeles has been aggressive in recent offseasons, and it finally paid off. San Francisco was more cautious until missing out on Stafford last year forced an aggressive draft trade to acquire Trey Lance. Will watching McVay, Stafford, and the Rams hoisting the Lombardi Trophy change the 49ers' offseason approach?
Brian Baldinger joined 95.7 The Game on Tuesday morning and was asked if the 49ers made a mistake by going all-in for Lance rather than pushing harder for Stafford in the first place.
"Yeah. Yes, to answer your question," Baldinger responded without hesitation. "Because if you put Matt Stafford in San Francisco, they probably win it all. But they built for the future. Now, they've got to figure out how to get Trey Lance up to speed. It's a slow process. I mean, Josh Allen has taken three years, and he still wasn't good enough. And we saw just how brilliant he is almost every Sunday, and he wasn't good enough in the moment to do it."
Stafford had a plethora of offensive weapons in Los Angeles, including Super Bowl MVP Cooper Kupp. He had a superb defense ready to help bail him out from any costly mistakes. It was still barely enough to beat the Cincinnati Bengals in the Super Bowl.
"It is a big task, once you get that guy, to make sure everything around him is just as good as it can be," Baldinger added.
Some, like Joe Montana, question whether Lance is ready to play, even after a whole season of studying and working hard to become Garoppolo's successor. Lance started just two games in 2021, playing 178 snaps compared to Garoppolo's 913.
"He's got to make a monster leap," Baldinger admitted. "... I don't know what the comp is to go from what we saw this year, which was spot duty, a couple of starts, to Super Bowl level. I don't know that anybody has ever made that kind of a jump. Maybe [Patrick] Mahomes might be the only one. ... It's hard to think that anybody can make that kind of a jump."
You can listen to the entire conversation with Baldinger below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Baldy reveals the key to 49ers success vs. Eagles in Wild Card matchup
The San Francisco 49ers face a daunting challenge in the Wild Card round, traveling to Lincoln Financial Field to take on the Philadelphia Eagles on Sunday. It's a matchup that many around the league—including NFL analyst Brian Baldinger—believe is far from ideal for Kyle... -
NFL insider says 49ers QB Brock Purdy's shoulder stinger "not expected to keep him out next week"
The San Francisco 49ers looked bad in their bid for the number-one seed in the NFC Saturday night, falling 13-3 to the Seattle Seahawks. But things almost got much worse when QB Brock Purdy went down late in the game. It looked bad, and there was immediate concern about whether... -
49ers mailbag: More two TE sets with Jake Tonges? Will Trent Williams play Saturday? What are the rules for signing players from teams not in postseason?
This is a big week for the San Francisco 49ers as they prepare to host the Seattle Seahawks on Saturday night. The winner of the game will be crowned NFC West Champions and will have home-field advantage throughout the NFC playoffs. So it's a huge game. For the 49ers, it's... -
49ers vs. Eagles: Trent Williams 'definitely more confident' about playing in Wild Card game
San Francisco 49ers left tackle Trent Williams is among seven players listed as questionable for Sunday's NFC Wild Card playoff game against the Philadelphia Eagles. The veteran offensive lineman has been working his way back from a hamstring injury suffered in Week 17, which...