Garoppolo did play through the pain of his torn ligament and chipped bone in that thumb. He put in a gutsy performance, leading the 49ers to a playoff-clinching 27-24 overtime victory over the Rams.
Head coach Kyle Shanahan did what he could to block out the outside noise, never giving in to the pressure to start Lance. It ended up being the right call, but the coach understands why everyone wanted to see the rookie quarterback so badly.
"I think it's human nature, I guess," Shanahan told reporters before Wednesday's practice as the 49ers begin preparing for this weekend's playoff game against the Dallas Cowboys. "When you trade up, and everyone's real excited, and you get a quarterback in the third pick of the draft, I think everyone's waiting to see. Just very rarely do two quarterbacks play. I mean, we did a little bit at the beginning of the year, but that's just not something that happens much.
"I think as soon as you have a bad record, and things don't look right, regardless of whether you have a backup on the bench that everyone wants to see, or whether you don't, when you're 3-5, and you've lost four in a row, whether you're the coordinators, the head coach, or the quarterback, that's just how it is. And when you've got a rookie sitting there on the bench, it's what's expected."
While the chatter was loud outside the building, internally, Shanahan and his staff stuck with the plan they've had all season. Garoppolo is the starter, and the inexperienced Lance would be better served by sitting and learning this season.
"That's what I kind of like about our building," Shanahan said. "I don't think it's something that people missed. It was just what you expect. That is what happens. And when you have an organization that, to me—we really don't splinter in here. Guys aren't just going to get caught up in that stuff and come and force anything like that. It allows you to make the right decisions.
"When you watch the tape, I didn't think Jimmy was playing that bad. I thought, as a team, there was a number of things we weren't doing well. But we'd all go back and watch the tape every Sunday night, Monday; that isn't what we saw. And we did think Jimmy was still giving us the best chance, and we wanted to give Trey more time. Not only just for him but also for our team.
"So it wasn't a tough decision. We just stuck with it because that's what the right decision was based off of film, and based off of where we are in our building and our practice. I'm glad the guys have come through and got us to this point, and I'm real glad we're still playing."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers WR Kendrick Bourne reacts to shocking Hall of Fame decision
San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Kendrick Bourne is not alone in his surprise over former New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick failing to earn first-ballot induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. On Tuesday, ESPN insider Adam Schefter reported that... -
49ers' Kyle Juszczyk says nearby electrical substation has been a 'talking point for years'
Discussion surrounding the San Francisco 49ers' recent injury history—and whether a nearby electrical substation could be a contributing factor—doesn't appear to be going away anytime soon. The 49ers endured another injury-plagued season in 2025, losing key stars such as... -
49ers mailbag: Will SF trade Mac Jones? Is there anything to electrical substation talk? Will 49ers be spenders in free agency?
Can't get enough of the San Francisco 49ers? We can help with that. We're back with a brand-new 49ers Webzone Mailbag. We asked for your best 49ers questions, and you came through with several good ones. Thank you for submitting those. Before we jump into the mailbag, be sure... -
49ers legend John Brodie passes away at 90
The San Francisco 49ers announced the passing of franchise legend and former quarterback John Brodie, a member of the Edward J. DeBartolo Sr. 49ers Hall of Fame. He was 90 years old. "The 49ers family is saddened to learn of the passing of one of the franchise's all-time great...