Key showed plenty of potential as a raw pass rush prospect at LSU, where he rocketed up mock draft boards after posting 55 tackles and 11 sacks in 11 games as a sophomore in 2016 before falling back a bit after a 33-tackle/four sack showing as a junior. Key slipped to Round 3 of the 2018 NFL Draft, where he was scooped up by the Raiders at pick 87 overall. He totaled 44 tackles and three sacks in 37 games with the Raiders before being waived in April of 2021, then landed a one-year deal with the 49ers, with whom he's found an important role as the current season progressed.
Key produced six tackles and no sacks over his first seven games with the 49ers, but since then his numbers have taken off. He has 14 tackles and six sacks over the past nine games and is now being looked at as a player the 49ers might want to prioritize this offseason. Whether the 49ers feel that way remains to be seen, but Garafolo seems to think some team is going to give Key a big raise in the coming months.
"I'm telling you this guy's going to get paid as a free agent," Garafolo said during a segment on the NFL Network's Good Morning Football Weekend on Saturday.
Garafolo said he spoke recently with Key, who admitted he was in over his head a bit earlier in his NFL career. But Key has taken a step forward over the past year, with the help of a defensive line coach and his teammates on the 49ers.
"I talked to him the other day and he said, 'First of all, I wasn't ready my rookie year. I've done a lot of maturing, a lot of growing,'" Garafolo said. "He also did some work this offseason with Mark Hall, who is a guy in Las Vegas who works with a lot of defensive linemen, and he learned a lot of the tricks of the trade. He learns it with the guys you see in Nick Bosa, Arik Armstead and the 49ers."
Key told Garafolo he's discovered the importance of hand placement from Bosa and Armstead, who also works with Hall in the offseason.
"'Every day we're talking about technique and all these things,'" Garafolo said, quoting Key. "'So yeah, you might be good and naturally gifted the way that I have been, and you try to swipe with your hands—everybody can swipe with their hands, but where exactly does the one hand go? And where exactly does the other hand go?' That's the difference between getting pressure, which he's gotten over his career, and getting the sacks, which he's now starting to get for the San Francisco 49ers."
Watch the segment below:
One would have to think the 49ers would be interested in re-signing Key, given the progress he's shown this season. Time will tell if the right price can be found for both parties.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers reportedly hiring Jerry Gray for key defensive coach role
The San Francisco 49ers continue reshaping their defensive staff under head coach Kyle Shanahan and new defensive coordinator Raheem Morris. According to Matt Zenitz of CBS Sports, the 49ers are expected to hire veteran assistant Jerry Gray to replace former defensive backs... -
John Lynch: 49ers expect Nick Bosa, key defenders back by training camp
Losing Nick Bosa to a torn ACL in Week 3 dealt a significant blow to the San Francisco 49ers defense, which struggled to generate consistent pressure on opposing quarterbacks throughout the 2025 NFL season. It marked the second ACL injury of Bosa's NFL career, with the first... -
Should the 49ers trade Mac Jones or retain him as a backup?
With Brock Purdy entrenched as the starter, the acquisition of Mac Jones as a backup in 2025 added a new dimension to the team's quarterback room. After navigating a challenging period in Foxborough, first-round draft pick Jones (15th overall) eventually made a successful... -
John Lynch reveals 49ers' top offseason priority ahead of 2026 season
The San Francisco 49ers entered the 2026 offseason with several roster needs to address. Some will be handled in free agency, while others will be targeted in April's NFL Draft. Wide receiver remains a question mark, and the offensive line has drawn increased attention —...