Specifically, Bill Barnwell is looking at the dominos that might fall should the Green Bay Packers trade Aaron Rodgers or the Seattle Seahawks trade Russell Wilson. That creates two scenarios for San Francisco, both involving some desperate teams who could seek out Jimmy Garoppolo.
The first is among the dominos that fall if the Packers ship Rodgers to the Denver Broncos. That leaves the Carolina Panthers looking to make up for the addition of Sam Darnold, which hasn't worked out as they hoped.
Of course, Barnwell notes that San Francisco doesn't have a ton of leverage due to the money owed to Garoppolo ($24.2 million base salary in 2022), the quarterback's inability to stay healthy, and the 49ers expected to move on to Trey Lance. But, of course, this only happens if the Panthers fail in landing someone else to take over under center.
What could San Francisco get in exchange for Garoppolo? Forget a first-round pick outright. That probably isn't happening no matter how the 49ers quarterback plays down the stretch. Barnwell does envision a nice alternative, though.
"We know that he has more upside than it might seem -- the 49ers did make it to a Super Bowl with him, after all -- and he wouldn't preclude them from going after a quarterback in the 2023 draft," wrote Barnwell. "This would be a third-round pick in 2023 that could rise as high as the first round if Garoppolo plays 16 games and Carolina makes the playoffs."
The second scenario is part of the dominos resulting from both Rodgers and Wilson staying put in Green Bay and Seattle. It has the New York Giants come calling for Garoppolo. Daniel Jones hasn't worked out as hoped, and this year's draft isn't a great one for quarterback-needy teams. So, once again, this leaves Garoppolo as a good Plan B.
This scenario has the Giants sending a third-round pick and Jones to San Francisco for the veteran quarterback. That provides Lance a backup with starting experience, who might even offer some competition for the starting job, pushing Lance in the offseason.
"As I mentioned in the first scenario, the 49ers can't expect to extract a premium pick for Garoppolo, but taking a flier on Jones gets the team a competent backup to push Trey Lance for the starting job," wrote Barnwell. "Jones might not end up as a premium starter, but his athleticism should make him a high-end backup. Garoppolo would be the short-term starter for the Giants, who could take a quarterback in 2023 if he underwhelms."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
ESPN analyst predicts 49ers over Bills in Super Bowl LXI
An ESPN NFL analyst is projecting a Super Bowl return for the San Francisco 49ers—and this time, a championship finish. ESPN's panel of experts recently released early predictions for Super Bowl LXI, which will be played at SoFi Stadium on February 14, 2027. Among the... -
George Kittle hints at potential 49ers reunion with Deebo Samuel
A return to the San Francisco 49ers may not be as far-fetched for Deebo Samuel as it once seemed. After requesting a trade last year and ultimately being dealt to the Washington Commanders, a reunion between Samuel and the 49ers appeared unlikely. However, tight end George... -
49ers insider doesn't rule out potential Mac Jones trade
The San Francisco 49ers may expect Mac Jones to return in 2026—but that hasn't stopped speculation about a possible offseason trade. Head coach Kyle Shanahan recently expressed confidence that Jones will remain on the roster, while refraining from completely shutting the... -
Where the 49ers landed in ESPN's post-Super Bowl power rankings
The 2025 NFL season is officially complete after the Seattle Seahawks defeated the New England Patriots 29-13 at Levi's Stadium. With Super Bowl LX in the books, attention has already shifted toward 2026—and ESPN wasted no time releasing its early NFL power rankings for next...