But that's exactly how things transpired after the third-round pick Sermon was an unexpected healthy scratch and Mostert left the game early due to a knee injury.
Mitchell, who was selected in Round 6 of the 2021 NFL Draft out of the University of Louisiana, finished the day with 19 carries for 104 yards, with one of those carries going for a 38-yard touchdown. Mitchell was impressive for the 49ers during training camp and the preseason when he was healthy, so his success when given the opportunity didn't come as a big surprise to head coach Kyle Shanahan.
"I thought he did a real good job," Shanahan said. "That's kind of what we expected him to do. But it's always tough in your first game and stuff. He went in there and didn't hesitate and ran the ball well."
Mitchell's involvement wasn't something many outside of 49ers facilities expected given the fact Sermon was seemingly higher in the pecking order during the preseason. But Shanahan said Sermon's status was never etched in stone, as was demonstrated on Sunday.
"We rotate everybody with the ones, twos and threes throughout camp and stuff. Nothing is ever firm, to tell you the truth," Shanahan said.
Also suiting up along with Mitchell and Mostert was second-year back JaMycal Hasty, who finished with a three-yard touchdown run and one catch for 15 yards.
"We only dressed three backs," Shanahan said. "You always try to do four, but those were the three after doing training camp and stuff that we felt were the three we were going to go with."
Mitchell told reporters after the game he was ready when his name was called on Sunday due to the teaching he's been given by running backs coach Bobby Turner.
"I was definitely ready for it. Coach Bobby T, he coaches everybody the same and keeps us all ready to go because things happen," Mitchell said.
And while he gave an assist to Turner for keeping him ready, Mitchell also gave some props to his blockers for helping him on his touchdown run -- which is certainly warranted given the size of the hole he was given to run through.
"As soon as I caught the ball, I saw George [tight end George Kittle] and them on the outside blocking their butts off," Mitchell said. "I saw the hole so I just had to hit it."
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers select Trent Williams 'heir apparent' in Mel Kiper's debut NFL mock draft
Longtime ESPN NFL Draft analyst Mel Kiper Jr. released his debut mock draft, and he has the San Francisco 49ers following a familiar path. With the No. 27 overall pick, Kiper projects head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch to select Utah offensive tackle Caleb... -
49ers Notebook: Purdy reflects on tough season; Jennings talks future; Kittle, Warner, and Williams recovery timelines
Monday marked the final opportunity for reporters to speak with San Francisco 49ers players at the team's facilities until the offseason program begins. The 49ers' injury-plagued 2025 season came to a disappointing end over the weekend with a playoff loss to division rival... -
49ers' Trent Williams sends a clear message about his NFL future
San Francisco 49ers left tackle Trent Williams will be 38 years old at the start of the 2026 NFL season, a milestone that naturally raises questions about his long-term future. However, the future Hall of Famer has made it clear that retirement is not imminent. Williams... -
49ers' Kyle Shanahan, Christian McCaffrey named finalists for AP NFL awards
The San Francisco 49ers are well represented among the finalists for this year's Associated Press NFL awards. Head coach Kyle Shanahan was named one of five finalists for AP Coach of the Year, while star running back Christian McCaffrey is a finalist for three major honors: AP...