But if Lance ends up with significant playing time, either due to an injury or poor play from Garoppolo — watch out. There will be no going back.
Ben Lyons was recently the guest host of The Rich Eisen Show and stated that it works out best for the 49ers if Garoppolo is the long-term answer.
"I think he's the long-term quarterback there," Lyons said. "They may not know that now. He might not know that now. But to think every Forty-Niner fan should be rooting for Jimmy G to be the long-term quarterback there."
Lyons went on to say that Garoppolo is still relatively young and has proven he can win—when healthy.
Added Lyons: "If I'm a 49ers fan today, I hope he's the quarterback for the next five years because that means he's continuing to win. … The idea of Trey Lance, right now, is better than Trey Lance."
Eisen could not disagree more, stating that he and Lyons clearly have very different opinions.
First of all, the 49ers traded away a lot of draft capital to move into a spot good enough to ensure that Lance landed in their laps. You don't do that if Garoppolo is viewed as a potential long-term solution.
"Garoppolo might start Week 1, Week 2, Week 3, what have you, and Lance will get in," Eisen said this week. "And if Lance does get an opportunity, which is probably going to happen because, you know, Garoppolo has trouble playing all 16, now all 17 (games), potentially. He'll get in there. And when he gets in there, and the light goes on, we'll leave the light on for you."
The competition within the NFC West should be intense. The Seattle Seahawks are always competing. The Los Angeles Rams now have Matthew Stafford at quarterback. Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray is always tough to defend.
"It's going to be deeper," Eisen said. "And if you've got a two-way threat, and you've got the running game ... (Raheem) Mostert and the rest of them ... and you've got a quarterback that keeps it and goes the other way, and Deebo Samuel coming across — maybe he's got [the football] instead of Lance, instead of the running back — look out, man.
"[Lance is] a much bigger, huger threat at the position than Garoppolo. Is he ready? Maybe not. You've got Garoppolo to sit there instead, under center, and he apparently looks terrific in training camp, all the better."
Eisen adds that the 49ers have put themselves in a great position, come the trade deadline, should Lance emerge as a potential starter this season.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Robert Saleh open to head coaching opportunities, but 'it's not desperation'
There is little doubt that San Francisco 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh will be among the top names to watch when NFL teams begin filling head coaching vacancies during the upcoming offseason. Saleh, however, has repeatedly insisted that his focus remains squarely on... -
John Lynch: 49ers locked in on Colts, not Aiyuk saga or playoff seeding
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch joined Bay Area radio station KNBR on Friday morning and was asked to reflect on the ongoing Brandon Aiyuk saga. The team recently placed the wide receiver on the reserve/left squad list, officially ending his chances of returning... -
49ers mailbag: What's up with Jordan Elliott's knee? Can SF stop Jonathan Taylor? What's on the 49ers' list for Santa?
The San Francisco 49ers are gearing up for the final push toward the 2025 postseason. How far they will be able to go will depend on their health and how many young players perform. Especially since some are reserves who are playing for injured players. We opened the 49ers... -
49ers vs. Bears: 5 Key Players Who Can Decide San Francisco's Week 17 Clash
Clinching a playoff spot before playing a game must be nice! That's exactly what happened during Week 16, before the San Francisco 49ers defeated the Indianapolis Colts 48-27. The win earned quarterback Brock Purdy NFC Player of the Week honors with a scintillating 295-yard,...