In his first two seasons as a head coach, Shanahan won a combined 10 games. However, his fortunes appeared to change in 2017, his first season in San Francisco, when the 49ers traded for quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo and the team rattled off five consecutive wins to end the season. Expectations were high entering the next season, but the team's hopes were dashed when Garoppolo was lost to a torn ACL.
Things seemed to come together in 2019. While the 49ers dealt with several in-season injuries, the team overcame adversity and powered its way to a Super Bowl appearance. Unfortunately for the Niners and Shanahan's legacy, the team fell just short of a championship as Shanahan squandered yet another fourth-quarter lead on sports' biggest stage. Previously, the New England Patriots mounted a comeback win against Shanahan's Atlanta Falcons in Super Bowl LI when the coach was the offensive coordinator.
Shanahan won just six games last season. Of course, he had to watch his roster get decimated by a league-leading number of injuries. In fact, San Francisco was the second most injured team over the past two decades. Only the 2016 Chicago Bears had players who miss more combined games in a single season.
Despite owning more losses than victories during his head coaching tenure, Conor Orr of Sports Illustrated is bullish on Shanahan. The writer recently ranked NFL head coaches and placed Shanahan at a respectable No. 9, noting that the 49ers coach is trending upwards.
Wrote Orr:
"I understand the complaint that Shanahan, a coach with a losing career record who has been responsible for a pair of significant lost leads in Super Bowls, should not be this high. However, any reasonable person looking at his body of work, his teams' history of injuries and available players at the time of major roster decisions shouldn't be too eager to dismiss his one Super Bowl appearance as a head coach as a fluke. Future head coaches will be pouring out of his coaching room in the coming years. Robert Saleh took the Jets job and with him brought Mike LaFleur, a name that will start to pop up in head-coaching lists. Mike McDaniel, Shanahan's offensive coordinator now, is another name that will be buzzing come coaching carousel season. The addition of Trey Lance only serves to deepen the mystery surrounding what this team will look like moving forward, but one thing is for sure: Shanahan has been ahead of the curve offensively for almost a decade now and shows no signs of slowing down."
As for the rest of the NFC West coaches, Pete Carroll of the Seattle Seahawks ranks highest at No. 7. Although, Orr believes he is trending downward. Sean McVay of the Los Angeles Rams ranks one spot above Shanahan, and Orr is neutral in his trending direction. Finally, the writer has Kliff Kingsbury of the Arizona Cardinals at No. 21, and, like Carroll, trading downwards.
Shanahan is entering his fifth season as a head coach. Last year, San Francisco signed him to a contract extension, keeping him with the team through the 2025 season.
H/t to Peter Panacy of Niner Noise for the find.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
George Kittle bullish on 49ers' 2026 outlook and Mike Evans addition
San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle continues to target Week 1 of the 2026 season for his return after suffering an Achilles injury during last season's playoffs. Appearing on The Pat McAfee Show, Kittle said there is plenty of excitement within the organization about... -
49ers among the Super Bowl LXI favorites, per ESPN's Football Power Index
The San Francisco 49ers are coming off a good season amidst a bounty of injuries, and ESPN's latest Football Power Index suggests they remain firmly in the Super Bowl conversation. This is despite some key players such as Nick Bosa, Fred Warner, George Kittle, and Mykel... -
49ers coach reveals potential breakout linebacker heading into 2026 season
Every morning, San Francisco 49ers linebackers Jalen Graham and Tatum Bethune make a point of stopping by K.J. Wright's office to ensure they are aligned with their position coach. Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, Wright identified one of the young linebackers as a potential... -
Why 49ers coach quickly fell in love with rookie LB Jaden Dugger
The San Francisco 49ers selected linebacker Jaden Dugger out of Louisiana in the fifth round of the 2026 NFL Draft. During the pre-draft process, Dugger stood out as a prospect with the athleticism, instincts, and upside to develop into an impact defender at the NFL level. One...