Brandt, who was a running back in college at Princeton, and Jones-Drew, who was a Pro Bowl running back with the Jacksonville Jaguars, decided to include the 96-yard game-winning touchdown gallop by former 49ers running back Garrison Hearst against the New York Jets in 1998 as their second favorite in league history. The run took place in the 1998 season opener on September 6 and sent the 49ers out on top 36-30 in overtime.
Hearst's run took place with just over 11 minutes left in overtime, not long after the Jets tied the game with a field goal at the end of regulation. Hearst took the handoff from quarterback Steve Young, then fought off a couple tackles before breaking into the open field. He ran down the sidelines, eventually accompanied by some blocks by wide receiver Terrell Owens and offensive lineman Dave Fiore, then held on as Jets linebacker Mo Lewis jumped on his back and tried to knock the ball free just before the goal line.
Click here for a look at the run on YouTube.
The play was originally intended to simply help move the 49ers out of bad field position after a Jets punt pinned them at their own 4-yard line. But Hearst gave them much more than they expected.
"We were getting to a point where we were repeating runs," then-49ers head coach Steve Mariucci said after the game, per SFGate.com. "It was just one play we pulled out of a hat. It was not divine intervention. It was one of four choices we had. I was hoping to get 4 yards or so."
Hearst's run may not even be the greatest in 49ers history (Steve Young's legendary game-winner against the Vikings in 1988 is a play many would choose), but it's certainly deserving of inclusion in this discussion, nonetheless. Brandt and Jones-Drew ranked the run behind Bo Jackson's famous 91-yard touchdown against the Seahawks on Monday Night Football in 1987. Take a look at the choices that the NFL Network show made below, with the Hearst run being featured just past the 6:30 mark.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Do the 49ers have the best quarterback room in the NFC? One NFL analyst believes so
For years, the San Francisco 49ers have been defined by elite offensive playmakers, Kyle Shanahan's offensive system, and a defense built to win championships. But heading into the 2026 season, one NFL analyst believes the biggest strength on the roster may be sitting in the... -
49ers' Brandon Aiyuk clearly has one NFL team on his mind
Brandon Aiyuk remains a member of the San Francisco 49ers—for now. The 49ers are expected to release the veteran wide receiver before training camp begins in late July. Still, Aiyuk appears to have already set his sights on his next destination: the Washington... -
49ers fans take note: NFL insider warns 'the 18-game slate is coming'
San Francisco 49ers fans would undoubtedly welcome another opportunity each season to watch their favorite team take the field. According to one NFL insider, that extra game is likely on the horizon—it's simply a matter of when the league and players can agree on the... -
49ers All-Pro George Kittle urges NFL to protect its most valuable asset
The FIFA World Cup 2026 is underway, with several matches being played in NFL stadiums, including Levi's Stadium, home of the San Francisco 49ers. To meet FIFA requirements, venues that typically feature artificial turf have temporarily installed natural grass playing...