There's plenty of room for debate when it comes to that question, but one answer from Cody Benjamin of CBS Sports has the 49ers head coach at number 11 heading into the 2021 season.
Benjamin's list of the top coaches in the NFL was posted Monday and was compiled based on both past performance and future outlook, with an emphasis on which coaches would be the best choice to run a team in 2021. Shanahan was the lone coach ranked in the top 15 with an overall losing record (29-35).
"You might be shocked to see that record, but here's how his 49ers tenure has gone thus far: 6-10, 4-12, 13-3, 6-10," wrote Benjamin. "Contrary to popular belief, he's not invincible, and his scheme can't cover every hole. But the 13-3 finish doesn't feel like an anomaly because his offense, when thriving, is one of the cleanest in the game. Gambling on a promising long-term QB in Trey Lance is a 2021 bonus."
Coaches with a winning record who rank behind Shanahan include Frank Reich of the Colts (28-20), Kevin Stefanski of the Browns (11-5), Mike Vrabel of the Titans (29-19), Mike Zimmer of the Vikings (67-47-1), Ron Rivera of Washington (83-72-1), Matt Nagy of the Bears (28-20), Jon Gruden of the Raiders (114-110), and Mike McCarthy of the Cowboys (131-87-2). Rivera, Gruden and McCarthy are the only other coaches besides Shanahan to have a head coaching appearance in a Super Bowl.
Click here to see the entire list, which is topped by Andy Reid (Chiefs), Bill Belichick (Patriots), John Harbaugh (Ravens), and Sean Payton (Saints). Should Shanahan be lower on the list despite the injury-plagued seasons he's had to battle through? Should he be higher? Or is 11 about right? It's an interesting question to consider at this point in his career.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Kyle Shanahan surges in Coach of the Year race after late-season success
San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan continues to draw praise after Sunday night's win over the Chicago Bears, a victory that set up a high-stakes Week 18 matchup against the Seattle Seahawks. On the line: the NFC West title, the NFC's No. 1 seed, and home-field... -
49ers coach Kyle Shanahan reveals key goal to beat Colts in Week 16
The San Francisco 49ers clinched a playoff berth Sunday after the Pittsburgh Steelers defeated the Detroit Lions. Still, the 49ers have plenty at stake heading into Monday night's Week 16 matchup against the Indianapolis Colts. Entering the game, San Francisco is slotted as... -
49ers Notebook: Inside the frantic final play against the Bears; Former Bear Jake Tonges has a night to remember; What makes Kyle Shanahan a great playcaller?
Sunday night's 42-38 win over the Chicago Bears was one to remember for the San Francisco 49ers, who now stand at 12-4 with one more win needed to secure home field advantage throughout the playoffs. The game was a back-and-forth affair, with both offenses putting up big... -
49ers' Robert Saleh open to head coaching opportunities, but 'it's not desperation'
There is little doubt that San Francisco 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh will be among the top names to watch when NFL teams begin filling head coaching vacancies during the upcoming offseason. Saleh, however, has repeatedly insisted that his focus remains squarely on...