After over a month of rampant speculation, Lance ended up being the selection. Based on the quarterbacks head coach Kyle Shanahan has preferred in the past, most analysts felt Jones would be the pick.
Was Lance the correct choice? Obviously, we will have to wait a few years to answer that with any assuredness. Fields ended up going to the Chicago Bears and Jones to the New England Patriots.
ESPN analyst Todd McShay was among those who believed the choice at No. 3 would be Jones, but he felt Lance was the better long-term prospect. McShay says the 49ers made the correct choice.
"I give a lot of credit to Niners coach Kyle Shanahan," McShay wrote in a feature for ESPN. "For more than a month, we've been hearing how Jones was the team's preference, but San Francisco did its due diligence with the other QBs, especially Fields and North Dakota State's Trey Lance, and saw the process through."
Lance gives Shanahan a dynamic passer who opposing defenses have to account for because the athletic quarterback can hurt you with both his arm and legs. The former Bison added 1,100 rushing yards and 14 rushing scores to his 2,786 passing yards and 28 touchdown passes as a sophomore in 2019.
Rather than 10-on-11 football, defenses now have to prepare for 11-on-11.
"Shanahan came up short in two Super Bowls with pocket passers," McShay added, "first as a coordinator with Matt Ryan in Atlanta and second as a head coach with Jimmy Garoppolo in San Francisco. And the second loss came at the hands of one the NFL's best -- if not the best -- second-reaction QBs in Patrick Mahomes. I really think Shanahan decided he wanted a QB who can extend plays, work off schedule and tuck it and run when needed."
McShay has been high on Lance. The analyst had the rookie ranked as his No. 3 quarterback on his pre-draft big board, behind Trevor Lawrence and Zach Wilson, and his No. 9 prospect overall.
"As a fit, Lance has a big arm and reads the field really well," McShay added. "He excels selling play-action, a staple in Shanahan's offensive scheme. He'll need to work on his accuracy a little, but he can sit behind Garoppolo -- unless the veteran is dealt -- for a while and develop before eventually taking over under center."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers restore locker room after Seahawks' Super Bowl LX takeover
The San Francisco 49ers locker room at Levi's Stadium looked a little different during Super Bowl LX — and not in a way 49ers players appreciated. Although the Seattle Seahawks were officially designated as the away team, they were assigned the home locker room and even wore... -
Will the 49ers draft a WR in Round 1? Two mocks address the same need
The San Francisco 49ers could take several paths with their first-round pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Help in the trenches—both on the offensive and defensive lines—remains a priority. The secondary could also use reinforcements. There's even a scenario in which the 49ers add... -
Barnwell proposes Mac Jones trade the 49ers might not be able to refuse
The San Francisco 49ers have consistently maintained that Mac Jones remains part of their plans for the 2026 NFL season. The veteran quarterback signed a two-year deal last offseason, keeping him under contract through 2026 and out of free agency until 2027. That means any... -
Where 49ers QB Brock Purdy landed in PFF's top 101 players of 2025
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy appeared in just nine games during the 2025 NFL season, missing eight contests due to a turf toe injury suffered in Week 1. Still, the former final pick of the 2022 NFL Draft did more than enough to earn recognition from Pro Football...