Still, there will be those who believe the 49ers should trade Garoppolo and that his trade value will plummet as soon as his eventual replacement is drafted.
Field Yates joined ESPN's Get Up! and explained why it might be in the Niners' best interest to hold onto Garoppolo for the upcoming season, which head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch have stated as the plan.
"We still plan on him leading us and getting as far as we can with him," Shanahan told reporters in March.
Yates states that if the 49ers wanted to take advantage of Garoppolo's maximum value this offseason, they would have traded him before free agency and before quarterback-needy teams started filling in their vacancies.
"Think about the suitors they would have had available at that time," Yates said. "Chicago, Washington, New England, all those teams that, at the time, not only did not have a new quarterback plan in place but had more roster flexibility in terms of cap space."
Instead, the 49ers held onto Garoppolo and waited until after the free-agency frenzy was over, and coincidentally, after Houston Texans quarterback Deshaun Watson's legal issues surfaced, to move up from the No. 12 overall pick to No. 3.
"I'm not sure that Jimmy Garoppolo is anywhere other than a Forty-Niner at the start of this season," Yates added, "because you're right, in the sense that the minute they draft a Mac Jones, maybe Jimmy G's value depreciates. But it could go right back up if he plays how they expect him to play.
"If they expect him to play pretty well this year, well enough that they could make a playoff run again, a year from now, they could have value in a Jimmy Garoppolo trade and an obvious transition plan to whoever they take at pick three."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Christian McCaffrey makes massive jump in NFL Top 100 Players of 2026 ranking
A fifth San Francisco 49ers player has earned a spot on the NFL Top 100 Players of 2026 list. Four-time Pro Bowl and five-time All-Pro running back Christian McCaffrey came in at No. 6, climbing a massive 67 spots from his No. 73 ranking in 2025. No. 6 on the NFL Top 100... -
49ers' Raheem Morris reveals what makes Shanahan vs. McVay rivalry so special
San Francisco 49ers defensive coordinator Raheem Morris has a unique perspective on the rivalry between Kyle Shanahan and Sean McVay. Morris has worked alongside both head coaches, serving as McVay's defensive coordinator for three seasons before joining Shanahan's staff as the... -
Jason McIntyre predicts 49ers could part ways with Kyle Shanahan or John Lynch after 2026 season
Jason McIntyre isn't necessarily predicting Kyle Shanahan will be fired by the San Francisco 49ers after the 2026 season. But he isn't ruling it out, either. During a recent appearance on The Herd with Colin Cowherd, McIntyre made a bold prediction that either Shanahan or Green... -
49ers' John Lynch addresses aging roster ahead of 2026 season
The San Francisco 49ers have one of the NFL's oldest rosters. That brings plenty of experience, including players who have been through some of the league's most important games. However, it also means the team's veteran core is inching closer to the point when age could begin...