Media chatter painted a curious picture after the 49ers traded up to the No. 3 spot on March 26. Because of the history of quarterbacks that Shanahan has worked with, speculation ran rampant, linking Jones to the 49ers.
The narrative has changed a bit since Justin Fields of Ohio State held his second pro day this week. 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch were in attendance, and Fields is now the favorite to succeed Jimmy Garoppolo in Santa Clara.
NFL Media analyst Bucky Brooks joined the Rich Eisen Show today and discussed the 49ers' options with their top pick. With several mock drafts still projecting a Jones-to-Niners scenario on April 29, Eisen asked Brooks who he believes the pick will be.
"Justin Fields or Trey Lance," Brooks responded. "I think the conversation about Mac Jones is just conversation. I think when you're Kyle Shanahan, and you move up, you move up to get a remarkable talent. And that talent, to me, needs to be someone who can not only do the things that you want to do on the script, but off the script.
"Because at the end of the day, what you're doing is you need to compare your quarterback to the other quarterbacks in the division. And if we're being honest, Rich, the NFC West has Russell Wilson, Kyler Murray, and Matthew Stafford. In any scenario, do we view Mac Jones as being the player that can be better than any of those guys in the next two to three years? Because if we don't, then we shouldn't make a move for him.
"But when we think about the extraordinary talents of the two others (Fields and Lance) that are mentioned, we can see how their athleticism and combination of arm talent could give them an opportunity to succeed and surpass some of those guys in the division. I think it has to be one of those two other guys, and I believe Mac Jones is just a smokescreen."
Brooks went on to break down Lance's skill set and NFL potential. You can watch and listen to the entire segment below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers expect Mac Jones back in 2026 as Shanahan and Lynch address trade talk
Speculation has surrounded the future of San Francisco 49ers quarterback Mac Jones, even though he remains under contract for the 2026 season. Jones played a significant role this year while starter Brock Purdy recovered from a turf toe injury, prompting questions about whether... -
What does the future hold for 49ers QB Mac Jones?
The San Francisco 49ers have quarterback Mac Jones under contract for one more season, and his strong showing in 2025 could draw interest from teams exploring a potential trade for the veteran backup and former first-round pick. Jones stepped in for Brock Purdy while the... -
Super Bowl champion 49ers safety Chet Brooks passes away at 60
Former San Francisco 49ers safety Chet Brooks has passed away at the age of 60 following a battle with cancer. RIP to my brotha in Christ Chet Brooks, I know we just talked a few weeks ago but God says its time to come home. Please pray for his wife Nikki and his son Terrance... -
49ers' Kyle Shanahan explains Brock Purdy's remarkable success in Seattle
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy earned his first career road start in 2022 with a 21-13 win over the Seattle Seahawks at Lumen Field. Since then, he has played three additional games in one of the loudest and most challenging environments in the NFL — and won all...