If the 49ers are to be believed, the transition won't happen this year, though. The plan is to keep Garoppolo for the upcoming season, allowing the rookie—whoever he may be—to sit and learn for a year. The team freed up enough salary-cap space to afford the luxury of holding onto Garoppolo for at least another year.
The 49ers win when Garoppolo plays. He is 24-9 as a starter. Robinson asked Staley about the doubt surrounding the quarterback, and the former offensive lineman provided an honest response.
"He took us to the Super Bowl. He was the quarterback when we went to the Super Bowl," Staley said. "I think one of the things you said was, 'When he plays.' I think in any position, if you miss a lot of games, I think the old cliché is, 'The best ability is availability.' There's a double-edged sword to that because if you're Tom Brady and Dew Brees, I don't care how often you get hurt, but you're going to still be the starting quarterback. I think maybe that's a little bit [of the reason].
"... I think, two, the way contracts are structured these days in the NFL, you're almost better off having a rookie quarterback on a rookie deal and kind of building a team around him. If you look at the quarterbacks [who have] been in the Super Bowl, Tom Brady's probably the only one that's not on a rookie deal that has been there. ... I think Pat [Mahomes] was on his."
Robinson added that quarterback Russell Wilson was on his rookie deal when the Seahawks won the Super Bowl.
"I think it's just the way the NFL works now," Staley continued. "I think everybody's kind of looking for the newest and greatest, and I think the one thing, too, is Kyle. I mean, I think any head coach wants this, especially when you're such an offensive-minded guy, like Kyle Shanahan is, is that he would love to kind of hand-pick his own guy.
"And I think, just looking from my perspective ... there seems like there's a lot of great quarterback options out there this year, in this year's draft. Obviously, they are excited about probably three of them if they're trading up to three. Maybe they've got three guys that they think are hand-picked guys that they could go for the next four or five or six years, be very, very competitive."
Staley adds that the 49ers have to be thinking about the massive contracts that will eventually need to be handed to linebacker Fred Warner and defensive end Nick Bosa. That's tougher to do when so much of your salary cap is invested in one quarterback.
You can listen to the entire conversation with Staley below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers QB weighs in on George Kittle's chances of a Week 1 return
San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle remains focused on returning for Week 1 after suffering an Achilles injury during last season's playoff victory over the Philadelphia Eagles. So far, the recovery appears to be progressing well. Kittle looked sharp during Tuesday's... -
49ers' George Kittle shares candid thoughts on bizarre Brandon Aiyuk situation
San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle recently appeared on the Pardon My Take podcast, and it didn't take long for the conversation to turn to soon-to-be former teammate Brandon Aiyuk. The situation surrounding Aiyuk has been one of the NFL's strangest storylines. The... -
49ers warned of 'recipe for disaster' that could derail 2026 season
Injuries devastated the San Francisco 49ers during the 2025 season. Despite the setbacks, the team still managed to win 12 regular-season games, earn a playoff berth, and secure a postseason victory while playing without several key contributors for much of the year. The... -
49ers fans take note: NFL insider warns 'the 18-game slate is coming'
San Francisco 49ers fans would undoubtedly welcome another opportunity each season to watch their favorite team take the field. According to one NFL insider, that extra game is likely on the horizon—it's simply a matter of when the league and players can agree on the...