Jets receive: No. 12 overall pick, 2022 second-round pick
49ers receive: No. 23 overall pick, Sam Darnold
"For San Francisco, this deal is the equivalent of two second-round picks for a talented 23-year old quarterback with untapped skills," writes Brugler.
Of course, that would likely mean moving on from Jimmy Garoppolo, who could be traded for a draft pick or draft picks himself, assuming he approves of the destination. He has a no-trade clause for this year in his contract. New England, anyone?
"Darnold's got the size and athleticism to extend broken plays, the guts to attempt any sort of throw and the arm talent to complete those throws," wrote Matt Barrows of The Athletic in a separate feature. "The projection (by Brugler) is that under Shanahan, a talented passer like Darnold would have the success he didn't have in New York."
While Darnold has been more available than Garoppolo over the past three seasons (23 missed games by Garoppolo versus 10 by Darnold), Barrows doesn't necessarily see the Jets quarterback as an upgrade.
"In just about every other area, however, Garoppolo has been the better player," added Barrows. "In an era in which elite quarterbacks have completion percentages above 70 percent, Darnold's has been a lousy 59.6 percent over the last three seasons while Garoppolo's has been 67.5 percent.
"One of Garoppolo's shortcomings is that he throws too many interceptions, 26 (vs. 46 touchdowns) since becoming the 49ers starter in 2017 with a troubling 2.9 interception percentage. Darnold has been worse, throwing 39 interceptions (vs. 45 touchdowns) in three years with a 3.2 interception percentage. Some of Darnold's struggles can be attributed to the subpar cast around him. But he committed a lot of turnovers in college, too."
Back to the mock draft — With a quarterback in hand, what do the 49ers do at No. 23? They pick up some edge-rushing help by selecting defensive end Kwity Paye out of Michigan.
"San Francisco was able to address the quarterback position without completely dropping out of the first round," explained Brugler. "And with Paye still on the board, the 49ers add a player they might have considered if they stayed at No. 12. Although he is still a work-in-progress, Paye has the athletic traits and energy to be equally productive vs. the pass and the run."
Paye recorded 97 tackles, 23.5 tackles for a loss, 11.5 sacks, a pass defensed, and a forced fumble in four seasons with the Wolverines. He had a career-high 6.5 sacks, 50 tackles, 12.5 tackles for a loss as a junior in 2019.
San Francisco has pass rusher Nick Bosa coming off an ACL injury, and veteran Dee Ford played just one game last season as he dealt with neck and back injuries.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Why the Seahawks listed Sam Darnold as questionable for 49ers playoff game
The Seattle Seahawks ruled out just one player for Saturday night's NFC playoff matchup against the San Francisco 49ers—tackle Josh Jones (knee). However, one designation on the injury report drew more attention: quarterback Sam Darnold was listed as questionable due to an... -
Seahawks provide Sam Darnold injury update ahead of 49ers playoff game
Few expect Sam Darnold to miss Saturday night's Divisional Round playoff game when the Seattle Seahawks host the San Francisco 49ers. Still, Seahawks head coach Mike Macdonald stopped short of entirely ruling out the possibility that his starting quarterback could be... -
Two NFL mock drafts have 49ers targeting offensive line help
The San Francisco 49ers' first-round position in the 2026 NFL Draft is now set following Sunday's playoff matchup between the Los Angeles Rams and Chicago Bears. With the Bears' loss, San Francisco officially secured the No. 27 overall pick, sparking early speculation about how... -
49ers' 2026 NFL Draft position finalized after Rams beat Bears in playoffs
The San Francisco 49ers' position in the 2026 NFL Draft is now set. Following Sunday night's Divisional Round playoff game—when the Los Angeles Rams defeated the Chicago Bears—the 49ers officially secured the 27th overall pick in the first round. That is one spot lower than...