Keep in mind that the 49ers used the No. 9 overall pick in 2018 to select McGlinchey, hoping the Notre Dame product would anchor the offensive line for years to come. With that comes the expectation of consistency, so every mistake is going to be over-analyzed.
Respected NFL analyst Brian Baldinger joined 95.7 The Game on Monday morning and was asked how he would evaluate McGlinchey's performance this season, and his response is interesting.
"Look, he ran into some really good players in Chase Young and Montez Sweat," Baldy explained on The Morning Roast, "and he knows he just got beat on the holding call, ducked his head, and overextended. It's a technique thing right there. But I think when things around him aren't going like they were a year ago, when they're not running the ball with the same ferocity and the same production that they had a year ago, then it falls on the passing game.
RELATED
"When you don't get play-action passes and some really easy looks — the run game really sets up the pass — when you've got to just line up and protect your quarterback on third downs and second-and-longs, and the situations they were in yesterday and throughout the season, he's not holding up right now.
"Maybe that's what he's always been, but when the season went like it did last year, when the defense was dominant, and the run game was dominant, and the play-action pass was really productive, it can kind of hide some of those flaws a little bit."
That led to a question about McGlinchey's future and a choice the 49ers will need to make about the young offensive lineman. Do general manager John Lynch and company choose to pick up McGlinchey's fifth-year option?
Said Baldy: "That's up to John Lynch, but if it was up to me, I would keep him because I still think he's a quality person, and I think that everybody can improve technique."
You can listen to the entire conversation with Baldinger below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers vs. Seahawks: Brian Baldinger breaks down the talent gap
The San Francisco 49ers' playoff loss to the Seattle Seahawks exposed more than just the impact of injuries. According to NFL analyst Brian Baldinger, it revealed a widening talent gap between the two NFC West rivals. Baldinger joined Bay Area radio station 95.7 The Game on... -
49ers named a top landing spot for Mike Evans
As the 49ers prepare for a pivotal offseason, it's no surprise that high-profile veteran wide receivers are being linked to San Francisco. With clear questions at the position, head coach Kyle Shanahan could be in the market for proven production. Brandon Aiyuk has made it... -
49ers add 'three-down disruptor' in 2026 7-round NFL mock draft
The San Francisco 49ers' work on revamping their defensive front will undoubtedly continue in 2026. After investing heavily in the trenches during the 2025 NFL Draft—selecting Mykel Williams in the first round, Alfred Collins in the second, and CJ West in the fourth—the... -
49ers' George Kittle is PFF's top TE — but can he return to form?
When it comes to elite NFL tight ends, George Kittle of the San Francisco 49ers still sets the standard. According to Pro Football Focus (PFF), Kittle was the highest-graded tight end in 2025, earning a stellar 90.7 offensive grade. Even in an injury-shortened campaign, the...