Former NFL head coach turned NFL Network analyst Brian Billick joined 95.7 The Game on Tuesday morning to promote his new book, The Q Factor: The Elusive Search for the Next Great NFL Quarterback. In doing so, he was, of course, asked about Garoppolo, who many feel might not have a future with the 49ers beyond this season.
Some question whether or not head coach Kyle Shanahan has a significant amount of trust in his quarterback, often pointing to last season's reduced role in the playoffs as proof that he does not. Billick was asked if he feels Shanahan trusts Garoppolo.
"Well, right now, no," Billick responded on The Morning Roast. "And probably for good reason. He wants to. They thought a lot of him when they traded for him, and he obviously has shown signs of being very good. What he hasn't shown signs of is being able to step up at the big moment in the big games on a consistent basis.
"Now, we don't have a lot to draw on, but that's got to be the biggest concern right now ... Now, obviously they're built to run the ball, and during the playoffs (last season), people were saying, 'Well, see, he didn't have a lot of big games in the playoffs.' Well, he didn't have to because they were running the ball so well. They were so dominant. So, it was kind of inconclusive.
"And now, it's even more difficult. One, because he's injured. Two, because he's just got no one around him. I mean, what did I see the other day? They went into the game with 70 percent of their productivity on IR or on the bench (because of COVID-19). So that's the difficulty for Coach Shanahan right now in evaluating (if) indeed does he have the right guy, is where is Garoppolo in his progression, and what's going on around him?"
Billick went on to say that nobody knows Garoppolo better than Shanahan and those inside the 49ers facility. That's something that the 49ers coach recently touched upon.
"I've got a good idea with Jimmy," Shanahan said last week, "and what Jimmy is capable of doing, and that's why he's been here. It's just people get better when they play more, and that's what I feel for Jimmy on. One, Jimmy gives us the best chance to win. He's proven that."
Billick says Shanahan and the 49ers will have to trust their evaluation of Garoppolo. If they knew in 2017 what they know now, they have to ask themselves, would they trade for Garoppolo again?
"You have to trust your evaluation, trust your people, and if there's a hesitation, if you don't think you would, then you move on," Billick added.
You can listen to the entire conversation with Billick below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Robert Saleh names 49ers' biggest rookie surprise from last season
The San Francisco 49ers invested heavily in their defense during the 2025 NFL Draft, using six of their 11 selections on defensive players, including each of their first five picks. One rookie, however, stood out more than the rest to former 49ers defensive coordinator Robert... -
49ers' biggest roster hole entering training camp identified by CBS Sports
The San Francisco 49ers made sweeping changes to their roster this offseason. While the additions of wide receivers Mike Evans and Christian Kirk generated most of the headlines, the team also focused on strengthening its defense. CBS Sports' Josh Edwards recently identified... -
NFL insider shares thoughts on 49ers QB Mac Jones' future
Mac Jones is entering his second season with the San Francisco 49ers and appears to be enjoying every minute of his time in Kyle Shanahan's offense. The quarterback signed a two-year deal to serve as Brock Purdy's backup, and that investment paid significant dividends for the... -
Brandon Aiyuk refuses reinstatement, accuses 49ers of lying as NFL future remains in limbo
San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk continues to air his grievances on social media as his tumultuous offseason drags on. The disgruntled receiver remains furious with the organization, insisting the 49ers wronged him. Aiyuk signed a four-year, $120 million...