Bill Barnwell of ESPN recently went through the NFL and ranked each roster's skill-position talent, while noting that he was not factoring in the impact of the quarterback, offensive line, or scheme. Just the weapons at the quarterback's disposal.
Neither contract status nor long-term values mattered because this is a ranking for each group's impact in 2020. Barnwell notes that he is also factoring in injuries, which impacted San Francisco.
"Deebo Samuel could be that guy (an impactful target) in the long term, but the Jones fracture he suffered in June is likely to limit his effectiveness in 2020," writes Barnwell.
How did the 49ers rank? The Kyle Shanahan-led squad came in at No. 18 on Barnwell's list, which was last in the NFC West. The Seattle Seahawks came in at No. 15, the Los Angeles Rams at No. 11, and the Arizona Cardinals were the best in the division at No. 9.
The defending Super Bowl champion Kansas City Chiefs, of course, came in at No. 1.
The top-level talent was valued higher within the ranking than strong depth. Barnwell notes that had depth been more of the focus, then the 49ers probably would have been closer to the top of the charts. The team is deep at running back and wide receiver.
"The Niners have one unquestioned star in tight end George Kittle," adds Barnwell, "who is the best all-around player at the position in the league, although I'd argue that Travis Kelce is more impactful as a pure receiver. At the same time, nobody who ran more than 200 routes in 2019 averaged more than Kittle's 3.3 yards per route run."
Barnwell goes on to say that outside of Kittle, who is a legitimate receiving target on his own, the 49ers threaten opposing defenses with consistent speed and the ability to extend plays after the catch.
With Samuel's injury, San Francisco will need young receivers like rookie Brandon Aiyuk and its second-round pick from a year ago, Jalen Hurd, to step up. Neither has taken an NFL snap.
"Guys like Dante Pettis, Trent Taylor, and Travis Benjamin are better than most teams' fourth and fifth wideouts," adds Barnwell, "but it's unclear whether any or all of them will make the roster."
Finally, Barnwell notes that Shanahan can create a successful rushing attack with just about anybody in the backfield, which is relevant given running back Raheem Mostert's request for a trade due to a contract dispute.
"Raheem Mostert led the league in rushing DVOA and still haunts the Packers after his postseason performance," explains Barnwell, "but it's telling that Shanahan has only been willing to use Mostert as a true No. 1 back when Tevin Coleman has been unavailable."
Update: We've been asked multiple times what the ranking was for the 49ers' offensive weapons leading into the 2019 season. It was No. 24. The offense finished No. 2 in the NFL in both points scored and rushing yards, and No. 4 in total yards.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers preseason: NFL Network and ESPN to air all three games
The NFL Network and ESPN have announced their preseason broadcast schedules, and all three San Francisco 49ers preseason games will be available to a national audience. Fans in the Bay Area can watch the games locally on KPIX. Those outside the 49ers' home television market... -
49ers' Nick Bosa appears to celebrate Ryan Clark's ESPN exit
San Francisco 49ers defensive end Nick Bosa rarely posts on social media, but he broke his online silence this week with a reaction to ESPN parting ways with analyst Ryan Clark, the former NFL safety—seemingly celebrating the move. 👌 https://t.co/hH903xy6zy— Nick... -
Only three 49ers would fetch a first-round pick in trade, says ESPN analyst
The San Francisco 49ers are widely regarded as one of the NFL's most talented teams. However, questions remain about the aging core of the roster and the team's recent injury history. Despite losing several key contributors to injuries last season, the 49ers still reached the... -
ESPN's ranking of 49ers' under-25 talent raises red flags
Much has been made of the San Francisco 49ers' aging roster as the team prepares for the 2026 NFL season. While the core remains loaded with proven veterans, questions continue to grow about how long that group can keep the team's Super Bowl window open. Sustained success in...