Bill Barnwell of ESPN, who joined KNBR on Monday, is among those experts. He envisions much more success from the 49ers with Garoppolo at the helm, assuming the quarterback can stay healthy.
"I think if Jimmy Garoppolo plays 16 games next [season], the Niners are a playoff team," Barnwell predicted on the "Gary and Larry" show. "I do firmly believe that."
Barnwell was asked if he would be willing to put money on that prediction.
"It depends on what the odds are," he responded. "Would I bet it 100 percent of the time? No. Do I think they have a very good shot, they'd be better than a lot of people think? I absolutely do.
"I think [the 49ers] are the closest example to last year's Colts. When you look at the advance numbers [in 2017], the Colts were a team that were very unlucky in close games, and their quarterback was gone for the entire year. The Niners were very unlucky in close games this year, and their starting quarterback missed 13 games.
"I think they're a team that, if Garoppolo stays healthy — before the year, that was going to be the biggest concern, he hasn't been healthy as a pro for any real length of time — I think they're going to be a playoff team. I really do."
You can listen to the entire interview with Barnwell below.
San Francisco is 6-2 with Garoppolo under center. The team is 4-20 during the Kyle Shanahan era without him.
The 49ers are confident Garoppolo will start throwing and doing non-contact work during organized team activities in late-May. One player who is excited to see his quarterback return is tight end George Kittle.
"Jimmy G, he's really good," Kittle said earlier this month. "I wish you guys could see all the stuff he does in practice because you guys have just been kind of teased on what he can do, just like the six games he played for us, and then the two-and-a-half that he played for us this season.
"He's going to do a lot of good things for us, and I think he's going to help out everybody on the roster."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers free agency: ESPN names aging pass rusher as best remaining fit
The San Francisco 49ers have made several notable moves in free agency, adding players such as Mike Evans, Dre Greenlaw, and Nate Hobbs. The team also traded for Osa Odighizuwa from the Dallas Cowboys to strengthen a defense that struggled to play consistent football last... -
49ers named among NFL's most improved teams in free agency by ESPN analyst
It may be too early to crown the winners of the 2026 NFL free agency period, but that hasn't stopped ESPN analyst Aaron Schatz from identifying several teams that have significantly improved their rosters this offseason—including the San Francisco 49ers. Schatz named five... -
49ers free agency: ESPN likes Mike Evans signing—if he can stay healthy
ESPN analyst Ben Solak reviewed the early waves of NFL free agency and came away impressed with the San Francisco 49ers' decision to sign wide receiver Mike Evans. Still, one concern lingers: injuries. The 49ers have been among the NFL's most injury-plagued teams in recent... -
Thomas Morstead thanks 49ers as time with team ends
The San Francisco 49ers are making a change at punter heading into the 2026 season, bringing an end to Thomas Morstead's brief stint with the team. San Francisco is reportedly signing veteran punter Corliss Waitman, a move that closes Morstead's time in the Bay Area after just...