Critics continue to note that Garoppolo doesn't yet have enough experience to predict sustained success in 2018. The latest to do so is ESPN analyst Seth Walder. During a feature looking at "bold predictions" for the upcoming season, he uses ESPN's NFL Football Power Index (FPI) to argue that Garoppolo won't even win more games than he loses.
What is the FPI? It is a prediction system for the NFL developed by ESPN's analytics team, of which Walder is a part.
"FPI knows that while Garoppolo has been incredible (career Total QBR of 77.8)," writes Walder, "the sample is so small that it's only reasonable to bet that he won't be quite the same player in the long run."
While Walder notes that ESPN's FPI ranks Garoppolo as a "well above average option" among starting quarterbacks, he also points to a feature by Bill Barnwell, which examines what is known and unknown about the 49ers signal caller.
It is important to note that ESPN's FPI projects the 49ers to finish 9-7, the same record projected for the Los Angeles Rams. Although, it also predicts a 31.5 percent chance that the 49ers will win the NFC West (46.5 to make the playoffs and 2.9 to win the Super Bowl) compared to the Rams' 44.8 percent chance (58.5 for the playoffs, 6.0 for the Super Bowl).
"But because of the aforementioned small sample — and therefore the uncertainty about Garoppolo's ability going forward — the model prefers players like (Carson) Wentz and Dak Prescott, who have lower career Total QBRs than Garoppolo but have a narrower range of outcomes," Walder adds.
The ESPN analyst also makes other "bold" predictions such as a Super Bowl rematch between last year's participants and the Buffalo Bills being awful.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
USA Today predicts 49ers record for 2026
Last season, the San Francisco 49ers finished with an impressive 12-5 record, despite many injuries to key players. Some injuries, like those to Brock Purdy, George Kittle, and Ricky Pearsall, lasted multiple weeks. But there were more devastating ones, like the season-ending... -
49ers' Lynch and Shanahan detail how Brock Purdy won them over early in 2022
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan recently appeared on the Tom Tolbert Show. They revisited how quarterback Brock Purdy quickly earned the organization's trust during his rookie season in 2022. Lynch recalled an offseason practice in... -
49ers mailbag: How much will Kaelon Black play as a rookie? Will SF sign any more free agents? Will the defense be any better in 2026?
The San Francisco 49ers have started OTAs (organized team activities), and there's finally actual football to discuss. It may not be like training camp, but it's close enough. And training camp isn't too far away. We opened the 49ers Webzone Mailbag to see what was on your... -
Brock Purdy: 49ers have what it takes to win the Super Bowl
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy attended this year's Dwight Clark Legacy Series event on Wednesday, where he sat down with NBC Sports Bay Area's Laura Britt to discuss expectations for the 2026 NFL season. Purdy has already experienced a Super Bowl run with the...