Foster underwent surgery to repair a torn rotator cuff in his right shoulder following Alabama's 2016 season. It was an injury that prevented the linebacker from participating in the NFL Scouting Combine and scared off enough teams that the talented linebacker fell to the 49ers with the 31st overall selection in the 2017 NFL Draft. Other NFL teams felt that the surgery wasn't enough to repair the injury and that another surgery would be necessary – leaving his 2017 season in doubt.
"Some teams looked at his shoulder as enough of an issue that, had they drafted him, they'd have immediately told him to get his surgery redone—feeling that the initial surgery didn't take," wrote Breer.
Of course, the 49ers and their medical staff were comfortable with the way the shoulder was healing. They were comfortable enough to move back into the first round and leap ahead of the New Orleans Saints, who were about to select Foster at the number 32 spot.
"Our doctors do a great job," 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan said earlier this month during an interview on KNBR. "They looked into everything with Reuben and met with him. Our doctors felt good about his shoulder. They thought it was recovering well. They didn't have the same report a lot of other teams did."
"I can tell you that anytime you have a player with a shoulder injury, there's some concern and you definitely vet it," 49ers general manager John Lynch said during a KNBR interview this month. "And we've got a great medical staff out here. A lot of doctors at a school about 15 minutes north that I'm real proud to be associated with at Stanford. They never deviated in their analysis of his shoulder and that was that he had a torn rotator cuff. He fixed it. They liked the way that the recovery was happening.
"Every time one of these stories would pop up, I'd go back and say, 'Are you sure?' What I loved is that they never flinched. They never blinked. And I kept getting the same report."
Regarding the off-the-field elements, Breer believes that the West Coast is a good landing spot for Foster because it is far from home.
"San Francisco is a long way from Foster's hometown of Auburn, Ala," Breer wrote. "Going into the draft, the feeling was that the further Foster landed away from home, the better. He had a very rough upbringing, and some teams were concerned about the crowd he grew up with."
Breer went on to compare the situation to wide receiver Dez Bryant, a native Texan. Many felt that Bryant needed to be drafted by a team outside of Texas, which, obviously, did not happen. He was selected by the Dallas Cowboys, who worked hard to put resources in place to keep Bryant out of trouble.
"The Niners are in a better spot with Foster (than the Cowboys were with Bryant)," Breer wrote. "And if his shoulder needs to be redone, well, it's not like John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan don't have a little time to wait on him, given the rebuild ahead."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Where does 49ers' Mac Jones rank among NFL backup QBs by trade value?
Mac Jones saved the San Francisco 49ers' season in 2025. That wasn't a statement any fan expected to hear before last season began. But it happened. And it's not an overreaction. Starting QB Brock Purdy missed eight games in 2025. And Jones filled in admirably, going 5-3, and... -
49ers facing harsh reality as NFL execs label Brandon Aiyuk 'untradeable'
There appears to be no trade market for San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk, despite the team's hope that interest could eventually develop. With rival teams believing the 49ers will ultimately release the disgruntled receiver, there is little incentive to surrender... -
49ers increase NFL-leading salary cap space to $72 million
The San Francisco 49ers made a couple of key contract adjustments ahead of organized team activities (OTAs), which begin today, restructuring the deals of quarterback Mac Jones and center Jake Brendel. While neither move added years to the players' contracts, the restructures... -
49ers owner Jed York reveals the only NFL Draft pick he ever pushed for
There's often a different energy when Jed York discusses players from his alma mater, the University of Notre Dame. For the most part, the San Francisco 49ers owner has stayed hands-off when it comes to draft decisions. However, in a conversation with ESPN's Jamison Hensley,...