The press conference kicked off with an amusing – yet odd – conversation about the grading system from advanced statistics site Pro Football Focus. A reporter asked Kelly why the decision was made to start rookie Joshua Garnett and Marcus Martin over Andrew Tiller along the offensive line. "Josh, obviously, earned his starting position," Kelly said. "When he came here, Josh was just a little bit behind because he missed the spring with us, obviously because he wasn't available for OTAs. But we got through training camp and we thought we had a pretty good one. As he got going through the season, he passed Andrew by and then, obviously, Marcus is playing center. Andrew Tiller is not a center, so when Daniel Kilgore went down, Marcus went in at center."
The reporter brought up the decision to start Martin over Tiller against the New York Jets. "Because Marcus was better than Tiller," Kelly explained. "That was that decision." The reporter tried to use statistics from Pro Football Focus to back up the perception that the call was questionable. After all, Tiller has a higher grade than Martin on the site. When told where the source of the stats came from, Kelly smiled and responded, "Stick with that."
Kelly was asked if he puts much stock into the statistics. "No," he answered. "I mean, I've said all along, 'How can they grade an offensive lineman when they don't know what the play is?' I've had it before, our left tackle gave up a sack. He didn't give up a sack because the guy slanted in the B-gap. The guard had B-gap and that's not the left tackle's responsibility, but it's written down as a sack on the left tackle because you don't know what play was called. We called slide protection. We didn't call man protection.
"So, if someone can look at a film and figure out what we call for a play and know what our scheme is and then give a guy a grade on it, then..."
Kelly then shrugged and continued, "I think there's a lot of players and coaches that feel the same way. I don't know. You can do whatever you want with it. It's like me going into a bank and grading the teller because they gave me a lollipop. I gave them a 94.3. You know what I mean?"
Kelly was asked about the analogy. "It depends on what lollipop," Kelly said. "It was purple and I wanted red, but they did give you a lollipop. You know what I mean? But I didn't know they weren't allowed to give purple out that day. So, if I did know that, I probably would have given them a higher grade but I didn't know the information going in."
"This is good," said another reporter after that topic was done.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Backup 49ers tight end labeled San Francisco's best-kept secret
The top of the San Francisco 49ers depth chart is loaded with star power, but the roster also features several reliable backups capable of stepping in when needed. That became evident last season when quarterback Brock Purdy missed time and Mac Jones helped keep the offense... -
49ers named ideal landing spot for two remaining NFL free agents
With the initial wave of free agency and the 2026 NFL Draft complete, most of the San Francisco 49ers' offseason roster reshuffling appears finished. However, the team could still look to strengthen a few key areas before training camp. ESPN's Matt Bowen recently identified... -
Why Pelissero can't imagine the 49ers ever firing John Lynch or Kyle Shanahan
The San Francisco 49ers have enjoyed sustained success since John Lynch took over as general manager and Kyle Shanahan became head coach. Still, critics have frequently pointed to the duo's struggles to consistently find impact contributors in the NFL Draft, particularly in the... -
Why 2026 is Brock Purdy's Biggest Season Yet
Nobody on the San Francisco 49ers roster enters 2026 under a bigger spotlight than Brock Purdy. Not because he hasn't proved he can win. Not because he hasn't delivered in big moments. But because somehow, the doubt remains. That's what makes this season different. Purdy has...