Out of all the key positions on the 49ers roster, the secondary remains the biggest concern. Essentially, the entire depth chart is up in the air with Richard Sherman, Jason Verrett, K'Waun Williams, Ahkello Witherspoon, and Jaquiski Tartt set to become free agents. 49ers cornerback Emmanuel Moseley was a restricted free agent but just signed a two-year deal for $10 million, while strong safety Marcell Harris was re-signed for one year. The lone starter who remains under contract is 49ers free safety Jimmie Ward.
49ers Secondary 2021 Free Agents
- Richard Sherman — UFA
- Jaquiski Tartt — UFA
- K'Waun Williams — UFA
- Jason Verrett — UFA
- Ahkello Witherspoon — UFA
- Dontae Johnson — UFA
- Jamar Taylor — UFA
- Emmanuel Moseley — RFA
- Marcell Harris — RFA
Initial Outlook
As it stands today, the 49ers have Moseley and Ward leading the group with questions aplenty behind them.
Moseley is a versatile enough cornerback to play either outside or inside, which gives the 49ers some options as to how they want to approach the offseason. Outside of Moseley, there are four unproven cornerbacks on the roster: Tim Harris, Mark Fields, Adonis Alexander, and Ken Webster.
Ward was the 49ers' starting free safety last year but is capable of playing either safety spot. Would it make some sense to promote Tarvarius Moore to free safety and slide Ward to strong safety?
The reason why I'm suggesting these possible changes is for the mere fact that it's going to be difficult to revamp the secondary in one offseason. The 49ers have the tall task of adding players with starting experience and/or youthful upside to develop this upcoming season. Their choices in free agency might be limited if the 49ers do re-sign tackle Trent Williams to a potentially massive extension. The 49ers have plenty of draft capital this year but it's typically a steep learning curve to develop defensive backs. Ideally, the 49ers would like to retain their own free agents but that seems unlikely--unless a tough market allows the 49ers to re-sign them at reasonable deals.
Free Agency
As noted earlier, the 49ers' approach to adding pieces in the secondary largely hinges on whether they retain their biggest pending free agent in tackle Trent Williams.
Out of the current group of 49ers free agents, it would be stellar if they're able to retain K'Waun Williams to continue his role at nickel back. Williams is one of the more underrated players in the league at a premium position. Based on his earlier comments, it's unlikely that Sherman will be back in a 49ers uniform. A combination of injuries and inconsistencies has probably run its course for Tartt and Witherspoon.
Retaining Verrett to a two-year deal at a reasonable price could be a win-win for both sides; I'm not sure other teams are willing to further bid for his services given his injury concerns.
The 49ers typically don't spend heavily in defensive backs with a bigger emphasis on the defensive line to set the tone for the secondary. I would expect the 49ers to go bargain hunting in the second wave of free agency after bigger free agent names like the Seahawks' Shaquill Griffin and the Bengals' William Jackson go off the board.
Perhaps the 49ers target veteran free agents on one-year deals while rounding out the secondary with draft prospects to contribute to later in the year. Outside cornerbacks such as the Colts' Xavier Rhodes, the Packers' Kevin King, and the Rams' Troy Hill come to mind. There also seems to be a good surplus of slot cornerbacks such as the Eagles' Nickell Robey-Coleman, the Lions' Justin Coleman, and the Titans' Desmond King. It might be optimistic thinking but the Raiders' Lamarcus Joyner, the Jets' Bradley McDougald, and the Colts' Malik Hooker are all good fits at safety.
Draft
The 49ers enter the NFL draft with 10 draft picks, notably with seven of those slotted in Day 3--including three fifth-round picks. The 49ers typically don't spend big on the secondary via free agency so I would expect the 49ers' front office to be proactive in this draft. Perhaps they trade up to get their guys, but given the 49ers' strong need to retool their depth, it wouldn't surprise me if they draft 3-4 defensive backs to round out the group.
Overall Outlook
The 49ers' defensive philosophy has always prioritized the front seven over the secondary but that doesn't mean the team can just get by with subpar talent—see last season against the Miami Dolphins with Brian Allen. They're going to need to find a good mix of savvy veterans and draft prospects to get their secondary to a respectable level; retaining a couple of their own free agents could help the efforts with stability in the system. Depending on how the 49ers play their cards this offseason, the secondary could potentially be the Achilles' heel to their defense.
Written By:
Justin Wong has been writing for the 49ers Webzone since 2017 while also running an NFC West blog and podcast called Just The West. Feel free to follow him, or direct any inquiries to @JustTheWest on Twitter.
All articles by Justin Wong
Justin Wong
Justin Wong has been writing for the 49ers Webzone since 2017 while also running an NFC West blog and podcast called Just The West. Feel free to follow him, or direct any inquiries to @JustTheWest on Twitter.
All articles by Justin Wong
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers announce roster moves ahead of showdown vs. Colts
The San Francisco 49ers are just hours away from kickoff against the Indianapolis Colts at Lucas Oil Stadium and have announced their pregame roster moves. Teams playing on Monday night have until the afternoon of the game to finalize transactions, unlike Sunday contests, when... -
Kyle Shanahan explains curious 49ers roster moves, sets expectations for Jordan Watkins
Twice this season—once ahead of a Week 10 matchup against the Los Angeles Rams and again before Sunday's game against the Tennessee Titans—the San Francisco 49ers elevated defensive tackle Sebastian Valdez from the practice squad. In both instances, Valdez was ultimately... -
49ers mailbag: What's up with Jordan Elliott's knee? Can SF stop Jonathan Taylor? What's on the 49ers' list for Santa?
The San Francisco 49ers are gearing up for the final push toward the 2025 postseason. How far they will be able to go will depend on their health and how many young players perform. Especially since some are reserves who are playing for injured players. We opened the 49ers... -
49ers vs. Bears injury report: Kittle sidelined, Pearsall returns, other practice notes
The San Francisco 49ers are preparing for their Week 17 contest against the Chicago Bears on Sunday at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, California. As expected, tight end George Kittle did not practice after suffering an ankle sprain in Monday night's win over the Indianapolis...