placeholder image

Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports


Richard Sherman points out flaws in PFF’s grading system

Jul 28, 2020 at 7:55 AM--


Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.
Let me first point out that Richard Sherman was Pro Football Focus' highest-graded (90.3) cornerback last season. The San Francisco 49ers veteran defender is one of just two cornerbacks who have been targeted more than 250 times over the past decade and allowed a completion rate of less than 50 percent. The other is Darrelle Revis.

Sherman is pretty good, and the analytics back that up.

During an Instagram interview with Pro Football Focus, however, Sherman didn't sound ready to endorse the analytics site's grading system. Let's be clear; the cornerback will often share social media posts from Pro Football Focus that tout the high level of play from fellow defenders—especially the defensive backs.

Despite being named among the league's best last season by the analytics site, Sherman pointed out why he felt the grading process, at least at times, could be flawed.

"I'll go games where I don't get targeted the whole game, and in your system, it's kind of like a flat grade for that," Sherman explained during the lengthy conversation. "There's no way to quantify that. But in terms of what we're doing schematically, and how I'm judged off doing my job and making tackles, and being sound, I'm usually right on it.

"And then I'll look up at the grade I'm getting from PFF, and it will be like, 'Well, we didn't have enough information. You didn't get targeted, so there's no way to give you a great grade.' Then it's like, what am I supposed to do? If I get targeted 10 times, and I can get a bunch of PBUs, I can get a high grade. But if I don't get targeted at all, [I can't]."

The interviewer noted that Pro Football Focus is working on finding ways to credit defensive backs who aren't targeted in games. He even invited Sherman to come work for the analytics site and help improve its grading system once his playing days are over.

As noted above, Sherman shares Pro Football Focus' posts, so he does find value in it. Is it perfect? No. No grading system is, especially when you don't have inside knowledge from coaches of what they expect from each player on every play.

Pro Football Focus' data is a tool. One of many that can be used in conjunction with others for player evaluation.

"I think you guys are doing a great job because it's so new," Sherman continued. "So obviously, it will evolve over time. You guys will get better. But there are so many variables involved in coverage, and especially when you're not grading it with an understanding of the scheme that they're running."

Sherman believes analytics can be improved by blending the data with input from those who had a much better understanding of what each team is trying to accomplish with every play.

"I think that you guys' system just needs more conversation," Sherman shared. "More conversation with maybe coordinators and players, I guess. Because the coordinator would be able to coach you up and say, 'Hey, this is what they're responsible for. This is how important it was to the defense.' ... There's too many variables."




Facebook Comments



More San Francisco 49ers News


placeholder image

PFF examines pros and cons of 49ers' free-agency moves

By David Bonilla
Mar 22

The San Francisco 49ers have primarily focused on bolstering their defense in free agency. This has included a significant overhaul of the team's defensive front, with notable departures such as Arik Armstead, Chase Young, and Clelin Ferrell. However, the 49ers managed to reinforce their defensive line with key signings, including Leonard Floyd, Yetur Gross-Matos, and Jordan Elliott. Additionally, they traded for Maliek Collins to help along the interior. Pro Football Focus recently analyzed the pros and cons of each team's free-agent acquisitions, indicating that San Francisco isn't expected to take a step back when it comes to rushing the passer. "Despite losing Arik Armstead and Chase Young,


placeholder image

PFF mock draft has 49ers finding potential replacement for Colton McKivitz

By David Bonilla
Mar 23

Pro Football Focus' Trevor Sikkema unveiled his latest mock draft this week and has the San Francisco 49ers addressing the offensive line. Specifically, Sikkema suggests the team seeks a potential replacement for Colton McKivitz at right tackle. In Sikkema's projection, the Niners select former Georgia offensive lineman Amarius Mims with the No. 31 overall pick. The analyst views him as an ideal addition to an offensive front that was untouched in free agency—apart from ensuring continuity among last season's starters. "Mims has one of the craziest builds you will have ever seen — in a good way


placeholder image

Latest PFF mock draft has 49ers making surprise pick in Round 1

By David Bonilla
Mar 25

The San Francisco 49ers focused on defense in free agency but still have several needs heading into the 2024 NFL Draft. The team did not address the offensive line, and it's a safe bet they will do so with some rookie selections next month. The Niners could also continue bolstering things on the defensive side of the football. Adding to the defensive back, defensive line, or linebacker groups remains possibilities. Pro Football Focus analyst Brad Spielberger released his latest mock draft and doesn't have the 49ers drafting at any of those positions. Instead, he has the team adding a bit of an insurance policy on offense, drafting former Georgia wide receiver


placeholder image

Terique Owens, son of Terrell, works out in front of 49ers scouts

By David Bonilla
Mar 22

Matt Maiocco of NBC Sports Bay Area reports that former Missouri State wide receiver Terique Owens worked out in front of more than 20 NFL scouts today at the University of Missouri. Among the scouts present were representatives from the San Francisco 49ers. Owens' performance was highlighted by a 40-yard dash time of 4.51 seconds, a vertical jump of 38.5 inches, and a broad jump of 10 feet, four inches. Terique Owens is the son of Hall of Fame wide receiver Terrell Owens, who spent his first eight NFL seasons with the 49ers. Missouri State WR Terique Owens, son of Hall of Famer Terrell Owens, worked out in front of


Latest

Trending News

Share 49ersWebzone