There are 200 users in the forums

2013 MLB Regular Season Wrapup Discussion Thread

Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by jrg:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Put yourself in his shoes though. From childhood on his dad told him the media was scum, and wanted to take advantage of you in any way to get a story. He was pre-trained to despise them. And as far as attitude towards fans, a mega superstar in any sport rarely is humble and down to earth. Michael Jordan was no more friendly to fans than Barry Bonds. When people constantly mob you for autographs any time you step outside, its hard to be super fan friendly.

He was better than everyone else, and he knew it. Willie Mays is the same way, but hes just more reserved about it. When he tells his stories for interviews, Mays basically says "yeah, I was better than everyone, i knew it, they knew it, and thats how it was."

Hes percieved by fans and media as cocky and rude, but he never did anything away from the game that reflected poorly on himself. He wasnt out snorting coke or assaulting people.

Like I said, if he played for the Cardinals for 15 years, youd love him. It should tip people off that Giants fans still defend Bonds vehemently, even after the Balco scandal and the perception of what a jerk he was. We know how special of a player he was. Its such a shame that people want to just throw his career out the window because of the steroids. They dont really have a clue how much of his performance and ability was legit outside that.

Trust me, I know. I was rejected of an autograph by Bonds personally.

He wasn't out snorting coke or assaulting people because he was too busy doing steroids.

You have this weird assumption that I just like all Cardinals players. Mark McGwire is a douche as well. Does that help you a little? I'm not a fan of any of those steroid users.

I understand what they did...and am thankful that the McGwire/Sosa season helped baseball tremendously..but doesn't make it right.

Barry Bonds could have been a special player without the steroids.

Aha...it makes sense now. Your opinion of Bonds is a bit biased because of that personal experience, wouldnt you say? What if he was in a great mood that day, signed your autograph, shook your hand and said "thanks for being a fan". You wouldve had a fond memory, and probably been more likely to defend him now.

I remember in 2003 the Giants went to KC to play an interleague series, and during pre-game warmups Bonds jumped over the wall along the 3B line, walked about 10 rows deep, sat down, and started signing autographs for everyone in the section. On that day, every Royals fan in that section of the crowd probably became a Bonds fan, possibly to this day because of that.

Bonds probably had a personality disorder, caused by being treated as better than everyone around you from a young age. He viewed life through a unique perspective. He grew up in Major League dugouts, with Willie Mays as a godparent. Reggie Jackson was his cousin, and he played with the Alomar brothers as kids. Most players grow up as regular people, and become famous later. Bonds was basically told he was special from day 1, and probably didnt even see making the big leagues as anything special, he had to be the best ever. The point is he was an odd person because of it, and didnt know how to come across as a normal person, especially to the media.

I think people miss the point about why Bonds used performance enhancers. He was the best player of his generation, and in order to prove it, he had to even the playing field with everyone else. He was willing to go down that path to prove it, and wasnt going to let other people's steroid use overshadow his career.

Mark McGwire isnt a good comparison here. He was never the same caliber of player Bonds was. He came to STL at age 33, played just 4.5 years there, set the HR record in 1998, and quickly broke down and fizzled out after being caught red handed with a hardcore, blatant anabolic steroid. He hardly had any time to endear himself as a Cards legend. The fanbase he built up with the 70 hr season fell apart shortly after. If Bonds had signed with STL in 1993, accomplished the same things as a Cardinal, and then retired 15 years later in 2007, you would view him as a legend like Pujols. You wouldve grown up with Bonds being your favorite player.

Bonds was a special player before the roids, during the roids, and after the roids. Did he have access to substances that no one else did? Because he was using what hundreds of players were using, yet he was the only one putting up Babe Ruth type numbers. If he had been 100% clean his entire career, he still wouldve been the only player in history with 500 HR and 500 SB. "the cream" and "the clear" shouldnt define his career. Giants fans who followed his entire career up close understand that.

99- you are speaking for us all and you aren't right. Older giant fans don't defend him like that. I think he was an HOF player before the roids, but he took them and f**ked up his integrity, honored statistics, etc. I have no problem with his outcast, regardless if I watched how great he was. Its the younger fans who grew up on Bonds that can't let it go. Ask John, others around 35-45, they will agree with me. He was awesome, but he f**ked up.
Miggy totally OWNED Mariano when it counted the most, only for the Tigers to lose both games.
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by jrg:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Put yourself in his shoes though. From childhood on his dad told him the media was scum, and wanted to take advantage of you in any way to get a story. He was pre-trained to despise them. And as far as attitude towards fans, a mega superstar in any sport rarely is humble and down to earth. Michael Jordan was no more friendly to fans than Barry Bonds. When people constantly mob you for autographs any time you step outside, its hard to be super fan friendly.

He was better than everyone else, and he knew it. Willie Mays is the same way, but hes just more reserved about it. When he tells his stories for interviews, Mays basically says "yeah, I was better than everyone, i knew it, they knew it, and thats how it was."

Hes percieved by fans and media as cocky and rude, but he never did anything away from the game that reflected poorly on himself. He wasnt out snorting coke or assaulting people.

Like I said, if he played for the Cardinals for 15 years, youd love him. It should tip people off that Giants fans still defend Bonds vehemently, even after the Balco scandal and the perception of what a jerk he was. We know how special of a player he was. Its such a shame that people want to just throw his career out the window because of the steroids. They dont really have a clue how much of his performance and ability was legit outside that.

Trust me, I know. I was rejected of an autograph by Bonds personally.

He wasn't out snorting coke or assaulting people because he was too busy doing steroids.

You have this weird assumption that I just like all Cardinals players. Mark McGwire is a douche as well. Does that help you a little? I'm not a fan of any of those steroid users.

I understand what they did...and am thankful that the McGwire/Sosa season helped baseball tremendously..but doesn't make it right.

Barry Bonds could have been a special player without the steroids.

Aha...it makes sense now. Your opinion of Bonds is a bit biased because of that personal experience, wouldnt you say? What if he was in a great mood that day, signed your autograph, shook your hand and said "thanks for being a fan". You wouldve had a fond memory, and probably been more likely to defend him now.

I remember in 2003 the Giants went to KC to play an interleague series, and during pre-game warmups Bonds jumped over the wall along the 3B line, walked about 10 rows deep, sat down, and started signing autographs for everyone in the section. On that day, every Royals fan in that section of the crowd probably became a Bonds fan, possibly to this day because of that.

Bonds probably had a personality disorder, caused by being treated as better than everyone around you from a young age. He viewed life through a unique perspective. He grew up in Major League dugouts, with Willie Mays as a godparent. Reggie Jackson was his cousin, and he played with the Alomar brothers as kids. Most players grow up as regular people, and become famous later. Bonds was basically told he was special from day 1, and probably didnt even see making the big leagues as anything special, he had to be the best ever. The point is he was an odd person because of it, and didnt know how to come across as a normal person, especially to the media.

I think people miss the point about why Bonds used performance enhancers. He was the best player of his generation, and in order to prove it, he had to even the playing field with everyone else. He was willing to go down that path to prove it, and wasnt going to let other people's steroid use overshadow his career.

Mark McGwire isnt a good comparison here. He was never the same caliber of player Bonds was. He came to STL at age 33, played just 4.5 years there, set the HR record in 1998, and quickly broke down and fizzled out after being caught red handed with a hardcore, blatant anabolic steroid. He hardly had any time to endear himself as a Cards legend. The fanbase he built up with the 70 hr season fell apart shortly after. If Bonds had signed with STL in 1993, accomplished the same things as a Cardinal, and then retired 15 years later in 2007, you would view him as a legend like Pujols. You wouldve grown up with Bonds being your favorite player.

Bonds was a special player before the roids, during the roids, and after the roids. Did he have access to substances that no one else did? Because he was using what hundreds of players were using, yet he was the only one putting up Babe Ruth type numbers. If he had been 100% clean his entire career, he still wouldve been the only player in history with 500 HR and 500 SB. "the cream" and "the clear" shouldnt define his career. Giants fans who followed his entire career up close understand that.

99- you are speaking for us all and you aren't right. Older giant fans don't defend him like that. I think he was an HOF player before the roids, but he took them and f**ked up his integrity, honored statistics, etc. I have no problem with his outcast, regardless if I watched how great he was. Its the younger fans who grew up on Bonds that can't let it go. Ask John, others around 35-45, they will agree with me. He was awesome, but he f**ked up.

I think Bonds would disagree that he screwed up. I think he feels like he did what he had to do to prove what he wanted to prove. I dont think he gives a crap if they let him into the HOF or not. If he cared about what people thought of him, he wouldnt have been such a douche to the media.

Where do you draw the line between the advantages you gain by rubbing (unbanned) steroid cream on your arms, and the ones you gain from getting to play your home games in a bandbox? I think people get way more upset about the fact that players tried to deceive them than what they gained out of that deception.

Fans are perfectly accepting of a player hitting 45 HR at Coors Field, but if he hits 45 at AT&T while using substances, its an outrage, and hes a dirty cheater. Its not the advantages gained, its the deception. Fans basically got butthurt that Bonds essentially lied to them. Bonds wouldve hit 756+ if he played for the Rockies and stayed clean. Same result due to a special advantage, but it wouldve been received as genuine.

IMO fans have to step back, realize how special of a player he was from 1986-2007, and get over anything that offended you about that era. Ultimately, choosing to view it as tainting the game will only spoil your memories of great times as a Giants fan.
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by jrg:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Put yourself in his shoes though. From childhood on his dad told him the media was scum, and wanted to take advantage of you in any way to get a story. He was pre-trained to despise them. And as far as attitude towards fans, a mega superstar in any sport rarely is humble and down to earth. Michael Jordan was no more friendly to fans than Barry Bonds. When people constantly mob you for autographs any time you step outside, its hard to be super fan friendly.

He was better than everyone else, and he knew it. Willie Mays is the same way, but hes just more reserved about it. When he tells his stories for interviews, Mays basically says "yeah, I was better than everyone, i knew it, they knew it, and thats how it was."

Hes percieved by fans and media as cocky and rude, but he never did anything away from the game that reflected poorly on himself. He wasnt out snorting coke or assaulting people.

Like I said, if he played for the Cardinals for 15 years, youd love him. It should tip people off that Giants fans still defend Bonds vehemently, even after the Balco scandal and the perception of what a jerk he was. We know how special of a player he was. Its such a shame that people want to just throw his career out the window because of the steroids. They dont really have a clue how much of his performance and ability was legit outside that.

Trust me, I know. I was rejected of an autograph by Bonds personally.

He wasn't out snorting coke or assaulting people because he was too busy doing steroids.

You have this weird assumption that I just like all Cardinals players. Mark McGwire is a douche as well. Does that help you a little? I'm not a fan of any of those steroid users.

I understand what they did...and am thankful that the McGwire/Sosa season helped baseball tremendously..but doesn't make it right.

Barry Bonds could have been a special player without the steroids.

Aha...it makes sense now. Your opinion of Bonds is a bit biased because of that personal experience, wouldnt you say? What if he was in a great mood that day, signed your autograph, shook your hand and said "thanks for being a fan". You wouldve had a fond memory, and probably been more likely to defend him now.

I remember in 2003 the Giants went to KC to play an interleague series, and during pre-game warmups Bonds jumped over the wall along the 3B line, walked about 10 rows deep, sat down, and started signing autographs for everyone in the section. On that day, every Royals fan in that section of the crowd probably became a Bonds fan, possibly to this day because of that.

Bonds probably had a personality disorder, caused by being treated as better than everyone around you from a young age. He viewed life through a unique perspective. He grew up in Major League dugouts, with Willie Mays as a godparent. Reggie Jackson was his cousin, and he played with the Alomar brothers as kids. Most players grow up as regular people, and become famous later. Bonds was basically told he was special from day 1, and probably didnt even see making the big leagues as anything special, he had to be the best ever. The point is he was an odd person because of it, and didnt know how to come across as a normal person, especially to the media.

I think people miss the point about why Bonds used performance enhancers. He was the best player of his generation, and in order to prove it, he had to even the playing field with everyone else. He was willing to go down that path to prove it, and wasnt going to let other people's steroid use overshadow his career.

Mark McGwire isnt a good comparison here. He was never the same caliber of player Bonds was. He came to STL at age 33, played just 4.5 years there, set the HR record in 1998, and quickly broke down and fizzled out after being caught red handed with a hardcore, blatant anabolic steroid. He hardly had any time to endear himself as a Cards legend. The fanbase he built up with the 70 hr season fell apart shortly after. If Bonds had signed with STL in 1993, accomplished the same things as a Cardinal, and then retired 15 years later in 2007, you would view him as a legend like Pujols. You wouldve grown up with Bonds being your favorite player.

Bonds was a special player before the roids, during the roids, and after the roids. Did he have access to substances that no one else did? Because he was using what hundreds of players were using, yet he was the only one putting up Babe Ruth type numbers. If he had been 100% clean his entire career, he still wouldve been the only player in history with 500 HR and 500 SB. "the cream" and "the clear" shouldnt define his career. Giants fans who followed his entire career up close understand that.

99- you are speaking for us all and you aren't right. Older giant fans don't defend him like that. I think he was an HOF player before the roids, but he took them and f**ked up his integrity, honored statistics, etc. I have no problem with his outcast, regardless if I watched how great he was. Its the younger fans who grew up on Bonds that can't let it go. Ask John, others around 35-45, they will agree with me. He was awesome, but he f**ked up.

I think Bonds would disagree that he screwed up. I think he feels like he did what he had to do to prove what he wanted to prove. I dont think he gives a crap if they let him into the HOF or not. If he cared about what people thought of him, he wouldnt have been such a douche to the media.

Where do you draw the line between the advantages you gain by rubbing (unbanned) steroid cream on your arms, and the ones you gain from getting to play your home games in a bandbox? I think people get way more upset about the fact that players tried to deceive them than what they gained out of that deception.

Fans are perfectly accepting of a player hitting 45 HR at Coors Field, but if he hits 45 at AT&T while using substances, its an outrage, and hes a dirty cheater. Its not the advantages gained, its the deception. Fans basically got butthurt that Bonds essentially lied to them. Bonds wouldve hit 756+ if he played for the Rockies and stayed clean. Same result due to a special advantage, but it wouldve been received as genuine.

IMO fans have to step back, realize how special of a player he was from 1986-2007, and get over anything that offended you about that era. Ultimately, choosing to view it as tainting the game will only spoil your memories of great times as a Giants fan.

Your right, I don't give a s**t if they played in a bandbox, as long as it was legal. Voters have long held it against those guys anyways when it comes to all star votes, MVP, etc.

Your right, Bonds doesnt give a s**t so why should I?

And I can appreciate how special Bonds was....I didnt need him to be extra-special. And don't believe for a minute he only rubbed the cream on his bi-Ceps. Lol
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Your right, I don't give a s**t if they played in a bandbox, as long as it was legal. Voters have long held it against those guys anyways when it comes to all star votes, MVP, etc.

Your right, Bonds doesnt give a s**t so why should I?

And I can appreciate how special Bonds was....I didnt need him to be extra-special. And don't believe for a minute he only rubbed the cream on his bi-Ceps. Lol

Wasn't illegal so what's the beef? You say you didn't need him to be extra special because you got to experience it. But why were no other players that "cheated" even near the level of Barry? Never before and never again.

Tell yourself all you want but there will never and has never been a player like Bonds.

He was ridiculous. Big Mac and Sammy did roids so did canseco. Why weren't they near the level of him? Not even in the same book


s**t wasn't illegal and frankly I don't care. I got to experience the most intimidating hitter to ever pick up a bat. Bonds almost single handidly kept the giants in sf
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Your right, I don't give a s**t if they played in a bandbox, as long as it was legal. Voters have long held it against those guys anyways when it comes to all star votes, MVP, etc.

Your right, Bonds doesnt give a s**t so why should I?

And I can appreciate how special Bonds was....I didnt need him to be extra-special. And don't believe for a minute he only rubbed the cream on his bi-Ceps. Lol

I admired Bonds as a player and still appreciate his greatness. But the fact is this... Bonds would not be the All Time or Single Season Homerun leader without PEDS. He never came close to 50 during his pre-roid years. Steroids helped put him at the top and this taints his records.

As for Bonds being the All time HR leader if he played his entire career in Colorado... pure speculation obviously and you could say the same for many players. Willie Mays could have 800 if he didnt play in the toughest park ever for a RH hitter to hit homeruns and miss seasons for the military. Imagine him if he played his career there. Bonds wouldnt have come close to Mays in my opinion. But, unless MLB makes every single park the same dimensions and at the same alttitude ( which is of course impossible) there will always be some advantage.

I have said many times that Bonds lost my respect for his use of roids just like Mac, Sosa, Aroid, Braun, Palmeiro, and the other users have. It doesnt mean I dont think he was an amazing player - perhaps the best of his generation ( although Griffey Jr might still get my vote) because I do. I just will never put him on some pedestal like many still do.
  • jrg
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 166,549
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Your right, I don't give a s**t if they played in a bandbox, as long as it was legal. Voters have long held it against those guys anyways when it comes to all star votes, MVP, etc.

Your right, Bonds doesnt give a s**t so why should I?

And I can appreciate how special Bonds was....I didnt need him to be extra-special. And don't believe for a minute he only rubbed the cream on his bi-Ceps. Lol

I admired Bonds as a player and still appreciate his greatness. But the fact is this... Bonds would not be the All Time or Single Season Homerun leader without PEDS. He never came close to 50 during his pre-roid years. Steroids helped put him at the top and this taints his records.

As for Bonds being the All time HR leader if he played his entire career in Colorado... pure speculation obviously and you could say the same for many players. Willie Mays could have 800 if he didnt play in the toughest park ever for a RH hitter to hit homeruns and miss seasons for the military. Imagine him if he played his career there. Bonds wouldnt have come close to Mays in my opinion. But, unless MLB makes every single park the same dimensions and at the same alttitude ( which is of course impossible) there will always be some advantage.

I have said many times that Bonds lost my respect for his use of roids just like Mac, Sosa, Aroid, Braun, Palmeiro, and the other users have. It doesnt mean I dont think he was an amazing player - perhaps the best of his generation ( although Griffey Jr might still get my vote) because I do. I just will never put him on some pedestal like many still do.

THIS.
Who has read "The Game Of Shadows"?. Giants fans who have read it feel free to share your thoughts.

It was a very interesting read.

Who read the other Bonds book?
Crazy how someone who never tested positive is condemned even though he used things that weren't illegal.


Not saying he didn't use Peds.

What about Luis Gonzalez? Dude hit how many home runs and his numbers aren't tainted? Bonds had one amazing HR season. Cool.

No one was ever that feared or pitched around
Originally posted by jrg:
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Your right, I don't give a s**t if they played in a bandbox, as long as it was legal. Voters have long held it against those guys anyways when it comes to all star votes, MVP, etc.

Your right, Bonds doesnt give a s**t so why should I?

And I can appreciate how special Bonds was....I didnt need him to be extra-special. And don't believe for a minute he only rubbed the cream on his bi-Ceps. Lol

I admired Bonds as a player and still appreciate his greatness. But the fact is this... Bonds would not be the All Time or Single Season Homerun leader without PEDS. He never came close to 50 during his pre-roid years. Steroids helped put him at the top and this taints his records.

As for Bonds being the All time HR leader if he played his entire career in Colorado... pure speculation obviously and you could say the same for many players. Willie Mays could have 800 if he didnt play in the toughest park ever for a RH hitter to hit homeruns and miss seasons for the military. Imagine him if he played his career there. Bonds wouldnt have come close to Mays in my opinion. But, unless MLB makes every single park the same dimensions and at the same alttitude ( which is of course impossible) there will always be some advantage.

I have said many times that Bonds lost my respect for his use of roids just like Mac, Sosa, Aroid, Braun, Palmeiro, and the other users have. It doesnt mean I dont think he was an amazing player - perhaps the best of his generation ( although Griffey Jr might still get my vote) because I do. I just will never put him on some pedestal like many still do.

THIS.

This. Not so hard to understand.

Originally posted by skeetskeet:
Crazy how someone who never tested positive is condemned even though he used things that weren't illegal.


Not saying he didn't use Peds.

What about Luis Gonzalez? Dude hit how many home runs and his numbers aren't tainted? Bonds had one amazing HR season. Cool.

No one was ever that feared or pitched around

Who gives a f**k about Luis? He isn't the homerin leader, nor the center of HOF ballot controversy.
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Who gives a f**k about Luis? He isn't the homerin leader, nor the center of HOF ballot controversy.

Again, wasn't illegal. Never tested positive.

Look at it this way.

Was Bonds great?

Did he change the game?

If you had to pick one player from the 90s who do you pick?

One player from the 2000s?

Should he be in the hall?

So he may have taken something, but never tested positive for it, and it wasn't illegal, yet we are keeping him out for that?


For hindsight?

For f**king HINDSIGHT
Originally posted by skeetskeet:
Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Who gives a f**k about Luis? He isn't the homerin leader, nor the center of HOF ballot controversy.

Again, wasn't illegal. Never tested positive.

Look at it this way.

Was Bonds great?

Did he change the game?

If you had to pick one player from the 90s who do you pick?

One player from the 2000s?

Should he be in the hall?

So he may have taken something, but never tested positive for it, and it wasn't illegal, yet we are keeping him out for that?


For hindsight?

For f**king HINDSIGHT

Skeet, if it wasnt illegal, why didnt they all just say "yeah, I did it!" Quit with the it wasnt illegal bit. I was tested for it in the early 90s in high school. We all knew you couldnt t do it.

As I've said, it has nothing to do with if he was great. He was great before he cheated. He cheated, so he lost my respect....along with the rest of them.
It wasn't illegal and they didnt test positive for any steroids because these drugs where designed to pass a drug test...
They weren't illegal because no one knew they excited!

Bonds is a cheating douche.
McGwire is a cheating douche.
Sosa is a cheating douche.
Braun is a cheating douche.
[Insert cheater here] is a cheating douche.
  • jrg
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 166,549
Originally posted by solidg2000:
It wasn't illegal and they didnt test positive for any steroids because these drugs where designed to pass a drug test...
They weren't illegal because no one knew they excited!

Bonds is a cheating douche.
McGwire is a cheating douche.
Sosa is a cheating douche.
Braun is a cheating douche.
[Puig] is a cheating douche.

agreed
Share 49ersWebzone