Originally posted by NYniner85:
be Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
This receiver is a stud, but darnit, he's not short enough! Said no GM ever.
What has been said is "This receiver can't do anything right, but by golly, hes 6'5"!" And, "this is the best receiever ever, but too bad he's only 5'11"" . Both of those statements get those GMs fired.
I highly doubt Shanny's requirement prior to this year was for a WR to be small, and I highly doubt Bellicheck draft NKeal because he's tall.
All these threads and posts about we need a tall receiver....no we need a good receiver. Being tall can be part of why you're good, but it is not black and white like the size queens seem to think it is.
THIS!
what people don't seem to get is Kyle has parameters at the WR position. quickness (foot speed), route-running, and the ability to get some separation.
You can be big, small, fat, skinny, white, black etc....as long as you can do what he asks. Issue is most big WRs are slow/can't run routes/and are stiff. When you can find one that can do what he asks and his big....you get Julio Jones
You are both missing the ball.
I have always said big WR and route-running ability are not mutually exclusive.
Since you all have documented what Kyle looks for in a WR, that pretty much explains itself.
Well, Kyle Shanahan drafted Hurd and signed Matthews and Poindexter. Based on what you all have said about what Kyle looks for in a WR, surely he wouldn't have selected those players if they couldn't run routes right? What in fact happened is Kyle went and looked for bigger WRs (who can also run routes that satisfy and indeed qualify based on his list of criteria).
I don't care whether in your view big WRs can't run routes, but at the very least in the eyes of Kyle Shanahan, Hurd, Matthews and Poindexter can. Because if they couldn't, Kyle would have never even touched them in the first place.
Moral of the story is this, you can look for big WRs that can run routes. And as far as big WRs go, you don't have to be Julio Jones to be able to run routes.
Case closed.