There are 119 users in the forums

Is Robert Saleh doing a good job in 2018

Is Robert Saleh doing a good job in 2018

with so many discussions going on... lets see what everyone thinks.. just vote!
[ Edited by kazak13 on Oct 16, 2018 at 4:52 PM ]
Pretty much know where this is going...
Originally posted by 49erWill:
Pretty much know where this is going...

i know i know.. i just wonder if its going to hit 90 percent approval on him being fired...
  • Garce
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 49,357
It's hard to say. The players are not well prepared I think that's fair to see. When they figure out wtf is going on they are half way decent. Second half of GB and KC for Example.


But it just seems like dudes are playing a bit dumb sometimes. Is that all on Saleh?
Originally posted by Garce:
It's hard to say. The players are not well prepared I think that's fair to see. When they figure out wtf is going on they are half way decent. Second half of GB and KC for Example.

But it just seems like dudes are playing a bit dumb sometimes. Is that all on Saleh?

someone has to take the blame.. i wonder how he would call plays if he had all the necessary players at position
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 16,958
Top 5 DC
Originally posted by kazak13:
Originally posted by Garce:
It's hard to say. The players are not well prepared I think that's fair to see. When they figure out wtf is going on they are half way decent. Second half of GB and KC for Example.

But it just seems like dudes are playing a bit dumb sometimes. Is that all on Saleh?

someone has to take the blame.. i wonder how he would call plays if he had all the necessary players at position

Lynch
He drafted Thomas and Witherspoon and picked up Mabin
He got rid of Elvis and Eli
He decided to do nothing about the secondary other than add Sherman
He decided to not to address the Edge
f**k NO. Robert Salad Tosser needs to go
Hellllllll no! Fire his ass nao! Along with the DB coach. Actually, fire all the defensive assistants as well.
  • evil
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 37,577
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by kazak13:
Originally posted by Garce:
It's hard to say. The players are not well prepared I think that's fair to see. When they figure out wtf is going on they are half way decent. Second half of GB and KC for Example.

But it just seems like dudes are playing a bit dumb sometimes. Is that all on Saleh?

someone has to take the blame.. i wonder how he would call plays if he had all the necessary players at position

Lynch
He drafted Thomas and Witherspoon and picked up Mabin
He got rid of Elvis and Eli
He decided to do nothing about the secondary other than add Sherman
He decided to not to address the Edge

Huh? What about Moore, Reed and Harris?

Originally posted by evil:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by kazak13:
Originally posted by Garce:
It's hard to say. The players are not well prepared I think that's fair to see. When they figure out wtf is going on they are half way decent. Second half of GB and KC for Example.

But it just seems like dudes are playing a bit dumb sometimes. Is that all on Saleh?

someone has to take the blame.. i wonder how he would call plays if he had all the necessary players at position

Lynch
He drafted Thomas and Witherspoon and picked up Mabin
He got rid of Elvis and Eli
He decided to do nothing about the secondary other than add Sherman
He decided to not to address the Edge

Huh? What about Moore, Reed and Harris?

How much are they contributing on defense?
[ Edited by TheWooLick on Oct 16, 2018 at 5:37 PM ]
  • evil
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 37,577
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by evil:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by kazak13:
Originally posted by Garce:
It's hard to say. The players are not well prepared I think that's fair to see. When they figure out wtf is going on they are half way decent. Second half of GB and KC for Example.

But it just seems like dudes are playing a bit dumb sometimes. Is that all on Saleh?

someone has to take the blame.. i wonder how he would call plays if he had all the necessary players at position

Lynch
He drafted Thomas and Witherspoon and picked up Mabin
He got rid of Elvis and Eli
He decided to do nothing about the secondary other than add Sherman
He decided to not to address the Edge

Huh? What about Moore, Reed and Harris?

How much are they contributing on defense?

Reed has contributed while Moore is a project converting to CB and Harris is on IR. We made the moves with an eye toward the future, draft and develop.

It wasn't doing nothing though.
Originally posted by evil:
Reed has contributed while Moore is a project converting to CB and Harris is on IR. We made the moves with an eye toward the future, draft and develop.

It wasn't doing nothing though.

"an eye toward the future" == too cheap to sign vets
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Originally posted by kazak13:
Originally posted by Garce:
It's hard to say. The players are not well prepared I think that's fair to see. When they figure out wtf is going on they are half way decent. Second half of GB and KC for Example.

But it just seems like dudes are playing a bit dumb sometimes. Is that all on Saleh?

someone has to take the blame.. i wonder how he would call plays if he had all the necessary players at position

Lynch
He drafted Thomas and Witherspoon and picked up Mabin
He got rid of Elvis and Eli
He decided to do nothing about the secondary other than add Sherman
He decided to not to address the Edge
In all fairness, I think most everybody was ready for Eli to be gone. Who knew he could actually play. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and say that his legs were stiff from kneeling while he was here and that affected his play, therefore the low level of support he got.
As long as we only have one decent player in the secondary and missing the most important player on the d-line it's hard to tell if Saleh has it or not.
Tartt, Colbert, Ward, Witherspoon, and Mabin look lost out there at times. Maybe it's coaching, maybe they just aren't good players.
Hard to see why the team chose Tartt over Reid and Witherspoon and Colbert were supposed to grow in their sophomore years, but they've regressed.
Salah should be on the hot seat. We have talent, so why is this defense getting consistently beat? Players are being missed used, and alot of mental errors, especially in the secondary. That's coaching.
Share 49erswebzone