Originally posted by 9moon:
Biggest Games = Montana hands down
Career Stats = Brady and who can argue
Argument:
Montana can play at this era and will put up same stats while The Big Five (Brady - Manning - Brees - Ben - Rogers) could have never put up their best stats during the 80s and the 90s when Defenses were allowed to play.
Yeah, tough to argue with what Brady has accomplished. One thing I'll say is that his longevity and consistency in his career is extraordinary. To be competing for championships year-in and year-out, and actually winning 5 of them--I don't know if we'll lever see anything like that in football again.
But I'll say this in defense of Montana though... What could he have done in today's era that favored the passing game, and all the rules/protections afforded to quarterbacks? If you recall, his later years with the 49ers were riddled with injuries and it was a much more violent league back then, The passer rating numbers for him and Steve Young are amazing, when you consider that almost all of the top 25 passer rating leaders started their career after 2000. Plus, he was a pretty good athlete. People forget about that because Steve Young showed up, but he was a pretty mobile quarterback.
People have been going back and forth on Brady vs Montana for awhile now... I think a more interesting discussion piece would be to analyze just how dominant they were in their respective eras. Without actually looking at the numbers, I'm pretty sure that Montana's passing efficiency relative to his counterparts in the 80s is significantly better... But then again, I'm pretty sure that Brady's WIn/Loss ratio and post-season appearances relative to his counterparts is going to be off the charts as well...
All in all though, players are meant to surpass the previous generation. It's evolution in sports. Brady learned from watching Montana and sports science is just getting better and better, year-in and year-out. Eventually, there's going to be a prodigy of an NFL Quarterback who has the clutch play and poise of Montana, the work ethic of Brady, the brains of Manning, the improvisation of Brett Favre, the arm of Dan Marino, the speed of Michael Vick, etc. etc.
This football unicorn is eventually going to come and surpass everyone else. We shouldn't be surprised when it happens.