Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by hofer36:
Originally posted by Loco49er:
Originally posted by Joecool:
Originally posted by drakan:
W-L Record
Alex Smith 6-2
Colin Kaepernick 5-2-1
Completion Percentage
Alex Smith 70.2%
Colin Kaepernick 62.4%
Average Yards per Game
Alex Smith: 207
Colin Kaepernick: 215
Both had the same receivers to work with. Since you're insinuating that Smith only makes easy passes while Kaepernick is launching bombs downfield. Why bother with the difficult passes when you can just make easy completions since both yield pretty much the same result.
They don't yield the same results. Smith's game has been inconsistent game to game. His game has also vastly dropped off when he's played better defenses. Like I said, the stats will not show why Colin is more dangerous to a top ranked defense. Top ranked defenses have eaten Alex alive more often...but in the past it was blamed on the WR's. It's because he won't make that downfield throw to an NFL open receiver. Versus the better defenses, all you're going to get is tight windows.
And then this comes all back to the "he's limited" conclusion. He can pretty up all the stats for you, but his on-field play is limited.
Kaep was horrible against Seattle and struggled against the Rams (which have an underated defense). The Bears have a good defense but at the time, there was limited tape on Kaep and it was believed that Alex would start. The other Ds have been middle of the pack. In the end, I think the bigger problem is Roman and not the QB.
kaepernick didnt do anything vs gianst defense either
Which Giants defense??
San Francisco Giants or New York Giants cause he didn't play against any of them.
Don't remember all the 3rd and long situations he created? That is convenient.
When??
Seriously I'm confused.
WildKaep, man, WildKaep! One of the postulations about why we stunk so bad vs. the Giants was the Kaep was inserted in the middle of a series, threw off the offensive Rhythm. At least once he set up third and long, then Smith came back in and pressed too hard to pick up and threw an INT.