-
TheXFactor
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 25,583
Originally posted by btthepunk:
Originally posted by Frisco69ers:
lol Rock has been dead average in games 2 and 3
And Dixon was even less than that in games 1 and 2. I HOPE that Dixon can play great on Thursday and stick around but Cartwright is and always has been the better running back.
yeah Roc is such a good RB, not. Thats why we gave him a 1yr deal. you guys act like he is a premier back
-
NinerBuff
- The Election Dude
-
- Posts: 21,443
My Take
with my percentage chance to make the team:
Offense
WR
15-Michael Crabtree - 100% (lock)
10-Kyle Williams - 90% (being backup PR and improved play)
17-A.J. Jenkins - 100% (lock)
89-Nathan Palmer - <5% (P.S)
81-Chris Owusu - <5% (P.S)
LT:
74-Joe Staley - 100% (lock)
78-Mike Person - ~60% (Backup tackle, but team may choose to keep WR/RB instead)
65-Al Netter - <5% (P.S)
LG:
77-Mike Iupati - 100% (lock)
66-Joe Looney - 90% (backup G, good future, essentially a lock)
C: 59-Jonathan Goodwin - 100% (lock)
67-Daniel Kilgore - ~80% (backup G/C, hasn't shown great improvement, but still very good chance)
61-Chase Beeler - <5% (P.S)
RG:
75-Alex Boone - 100% (lock)
68-Leonard Davis - ~80% (backup G, good veteran presence, team may choose to go younger, still very good chance)
71-Derek Hall - <5% (P.S)
RT:
76-Anthony Davis - 100% (lock)
69-Kenny Wiggins - <5% (P.S)
TE:
85-Vernon Davis - 100% (lock)
46-Delanie Walker - 100% (lock)
88-Konrad Reuland - ~40% (good offseason, but remains to be seen if they keep 3 TEs, plus Dobbs may push him out)
48-Garrett Celek - <5% (P.S)
47-Kyle Nelson - <5% (P.S)
WR:
19-Ted Ginn - 90% (Great returner, has some skills at WR, injuries only concern, essentially a lock)
84-Randy Moss - 90% (Exceeded expectations, only reason I didn't put lock is his contract can be voided at any time, essentially a lock)
14-Mario Manningham - 100% (lock)
18-Brett Swain - ~10% (had a good offseason, but too much talent above him, very doubtful)
FB:
49-Bruce Miller - 100% (lock)
24-Anthony Dixon - ~60% (good offseason, also incorporated FB position, will come down to him or Cartwright)
RB:
21-Frank Gore - 100% (lock)
32-Kendall Hunter - 100% (lock)
45-Brandon Jacobs - ~80% (good burst, good teammate, injury a concern, but overall very good chance to make the team)
23-LaMichael James - 100% (lock)
28 Rock Cartwright - ~40% (between him and Dixon)
QB:
11-Alex Smith - 100% (lock)
7-Colin Kaepernick - 100% (lock)
1-Josh Johnson - ~40% (has a better skill set than Tolzien, but not the poise, team may only take 2 QBs)
3-Scott Tolzien - ~40% (better intangibles than Johnson, but not as gifted of a thrower, team may only take 2 QBs, PS possible)
Defense
LDT:
91-Ray McDonald - 100% (lock)
95-Ricky Jean Francois - 100% (lock)
40-Demarcus Dobbs - ~80% (backup D-line, backup TE has made his case for the team, injury only the concern)
NT:
90-Isaac Sopoaga - 100% (lock)
93-Ian Williams - 80% (only true backup NT)
53-Tony Jerod-Eddie - <5% (P.S)
RDT:
94-Justin Smith - 100% (lock)
92-Will Tukuafu - ~40% (has had good offseason, could improve his chances if he lands backup FB spot too)
OLB:
55-Ahmad Brooks - 100% (lock)
98-Parys Haralson - 100% (lock)
44-Eric Bakhtiari - ~40% (good burst, but injured at the wrong time, less physical than Alama-Francis)
50-Cam Johnson - ~20% (injured and non-factor in offseason, good chance at PS)
ILB:
53-NaVorro Bowman - 100% (lock)
54-Larry Grant - 100% (lock)
51-Joe Holland - <5% (P.S)
ILB:
52-Patrick Willis - 100% (lock)
56-Tavares Gooden - ~80% (second backup ILB, good ST value, good chance at making roster)
57-Michael Wilhoite - <5% (P.S)
OLB:
99-Aldon Smith - 100% (lock)
41-Kenny Rowe - <5% (P.S)
47-Ikaika Alama-Francis - ~20% (low chance at making team due to being signed late, but is physically imposing)
LCB:
22-Carlos Rogers - 100% (lock)
26-Tramaine Brock - ~60% (bad showing in preseason, seems to have been surpassed by Cox, still could make the 5th CB spot)
20-Perrish Cox - ~80% (good showing during offseason, seems to be 4th CB)
RCB:
25-Tarell Brown - 100% (lock)
29-Chris Culliver - 100% (lock)
33-Anthony Mosley - <5% (P.S)
FS:
38-Dashon Goldson - 100% (lock)
27-C.J. Spillman - 100% (lock)
43-Colin Jones - ~40% (must show great value at ST to make team)
SS:
31-Donte Whitner - 100% (lock)
30-Trenton Robinson - ~60% (draft status carries some weight, but unimpressive so far)
32-Darcel McBath - ~60% (seems to have surpassed Robinson as 4th Safety)
36-Michael Thomas - <5% (P.S)
SPECIAL TEAMS
P:
4-Andy Lee - 100% (lock)
K:
2-David Akers - 100% (lock)
LS:
86-Brian Jennings - 100% (lock)
100% Locks:
34 Players
80% or Greater:
11 players
Remaining Roster Spots:
8 players from the 13 listed below:
Person, Reuland, Dixon, Cartwright, Johnson, Tolzien, Tukuafu, Bakhtiari, Alama-Francis, Brock, Jones, Robinson, and McBath
-
btthepunk
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 22,544
Originally posted by Frisco69ers:
yeah Roc is such a good RB, not. Thats why we gave him a 1yr deal. you guys act like he is a premier back
Just like your acting like Dixon is a premier back. If both are cut, Cartwright would get signed before Dixon.
-
TheXFactor
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 25,583
Originally posted by btthepunk:
Originally posted by Frisco69ers:
yeah Roc is such a good RB, not. Thats why we gave him a 1yr deal. you guys act like he is a premier back
Just like your acting like Dixon is a premier back. If both are cut, Cartwright would get signed before Dixon.
Dixon is not a premier back but he is more useful than old Roc.
-
boast
- Hella Fame
-
- Posts: 149,561
Roman's comments this morning hint at Dixon sticking around.
-
paulk205
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 824
Originally posted by btthepunk:
If both are cut, Cartwright would get signed before Dixon.
That's the thing. It's not as if these guys are likely to go to other teams if they don't make the 53.
I think the best way to go about the 53 is to start with who are the 46 that dress (if the team are perfectly healthy) and then add those who are unlikely to dress but need to be protected in the 53 (AJ Jenkins, possibly James). I also think we'll go at least with 10 and possibly 11 DBs.
-
TheXFactor
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 25,583
Originally posted by paulk205:
Originally posted by btthepunk:
If both are cut, Cartwright would get signed before Dixon.
That's the thing. It's not as if these guys are likely to go to other teams if they don't make the 53.
I think the best way to go about the 53 is to start with who are the 46 that dress (if the team are perfectly healthy) and then add those who are unlikely to dress but need to be protected in the 53 (AJ Jenkins, possibly James). I also think we'll go at least with 10 and possibly 11 DBs.
i wish that the nfl would let the teams dress all 53 on gamedays
Originally posted by boast:
Roman's comments this morning hint at Dixon sticking around.
I'd say it was more than just a hint.
-
Bootlegger
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 761
This is my best guess for who will make the 53 man roster.
QBS
Smith
Kaepernick
Tolzien
OLINE
Staley
Iupati
Goodwin
Boone
A. Davis
L. Davis
Looney
Kilgore
RB/FB
Gore
Hunter
Jacobs
James
Miller
WR
Crabtree
Moss
Manningham
Williams
Ginn
Jenkins
Owusu
TE
Davis
Walker
Reuland
26
DLINE
Smith
Sopoaga
McDonald
Dobbs
Jean-Francois
Williams
Tukuafu
ILB
Willis
Bowman
Grant
Gooden
OLB
Brooks
Smith
Haralson
Bakhtiari
CB
Rogers
Culliver
Cox
Brown
Brock
SAFETY
Whitner
Goldson
Spillman
49
ST
Lee
Akers
Jennings
Dixon
53
*edit replaced Swain with Jenkins.
[ Edited by Bootlegger on Aug 28, 2012 at 1:21 PM ]
-
phatbutskinny
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 27,247
unfortunately, i think Dixon is gunna make it
Originally posted by Bootlegger:
This is my best guess for who will make the 53 man roster.
QBS
Smith
Kaepernick
Tolzien
OLINE
Staley
Iupati
Goodwin
Boone
A. Davis
L. Davis
Looney
Kilgore
RB/FB
Gore
Hunter
Jacobs
James
Miller
WR
Crabtree
Moss
Manningham
Williams
Ginn
Swain
Owusu
TE
Davis
Walker
Reuland
26
DLINE
Smith
Sopoaga
McDonald
Dobbs
Jean-Francois
Williams
Tukuafu
ILB
Willis
Bowman
Grant
Gooden
OLB
Brooks
Smith
Haralson
Bakhtiari
CB
Rogers
Culliver
Cox
Brown
Brock
SAFETY
Whitner
Goldson
Spillman
49
ST
Lee
Akers
Jennings
Dixon
53
So we're gonna set an NFL record by keeping 7 WR's, none of which are our 1st round pick?
-
AB81Rules
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 32,809
ughh, Ginn better not be cut. I have no faith in Kyle Williams, LaMichael James or anyone else on returns.
I feel Leonard Davis is one of the best 53 players, and versatile, so he makes it and is active on sundays.