Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Eh Brooks is pretty good, he's better than any other OLB on the market in this class of free agents but yeah Rogers is better and more important to our defense. Brooks is replaceable IMO because you can get a rookie OLB/DE like a Jake Bequette or Cam Johnson in the 3rd round to come in and rush the passer on 3rd downs, and on first and 2nd you can just place Haralson and Aldon at the 2 OLB spots. Plus there is always someone who gets cut that's a Jason Taylor type player that you can have come in as a vet and they may not be able to play all the downs but they can give you some good snaps. We can't find anyone to come in and alternate covering the other team's best reciever and the slot reciever 1 on 1 like Rogers did, and also get 6 INTS. That is a friggin super star season right there. Rogers and Goldson are really important to keep around. Brooks is a little bit less so. Would like him back but he's replaceable. So for the most part I agree with el guapo.
Good objective post and you backed it up well.
So curious...if Brooks leaves what is your solution and how does that change our depth, FA and draft? Would you slide Aldon over to SAM and continue to start Haralson at WILL on 1st and 2nd downs and then draft a pass rusher for 3rd downs from the WILL spot? If so, you lose huge production all the way around. First, we may never see another rookie in history collect 14 sacks from the WILL spot as a 3rd down specialist. Second, you move Aldon to a completely different position, start him and have him rush from the site-line of a QB. Then who backs up Aldon should he go down? Fatigue taking on two blockers all year and sealing the edge?
No? OK, then let's start Aldon at WILL and move Haralson to SAM. You can naturally expect Aldon's sack numbers from teams having tape on him and him starting every snap to go down (see also, Haralson)...more focus on sealing the edges too and dropping back and fatigue and more double-teams. This may be the best solution. But then you'd still want to draft a pass rusher high affecting your draft strategy, bring in depth via FA, etc. But I have some big concerns here for Haralson. He is a solid run stopper but that's paired with Justin Smith. McDonald is more of an up-the-field, slip-through-the-cracks, slasher of a RDE unlike Justin who not only takes on two guys but pushes them both backwards and STILL produces sacks/pressures. McDonald can do this b/c he knows Brooks can contain the edge, make TFL's and funnel action back into Willis/Bowman while taking on two guys (ala Justin). Haralson BLOWS in space...if he can only get two sacks (theme for him) in the first game of the year playing on the weak/blind side, he's going to provide next to nothing on the SAM side. And coverage? Reading AND defending screens? Scary. And he sort of has a history of RB's running off his edge too. Now imagine him at SAM with an extra TE, RT and FB coming at him...meat!
So what are your solutions?